Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
Professional malpractice involves claims against professionals - for example doctors, dentists, lawyers, engineers, architects, accountants - who are alleged to have caused harm by failing to perform to the standard expected in their field. In Sassuolo, which is in the Province of Modena, malpractice matters are governed by national Italian law as applied by local courts and professional orders. Cases can raise civil liability for damages, disciplinary proceedings before the relevant professional order, and in serious cases criminal proceedings before the Procura della Repubblica.
You may need a lawyer if you believe you suffered harm because a professional did not exercise proper care or skill. Common situations include:
- Medical malpractice: misdiagnosis, surgical errors, medication mistakes, delayed treatment or lack of informed consent.
- Legal malpractice: missed deadlines, poor advice, conflict of interest, inadequate representation causing loss in a case.
- Technical professional malpractice: engineering or architectural defects that cause damage or danger, accounting errors that cause financial loss.
A lawyer helps in assessing whether you have a viable claim, gathering evidence, instructing expert witnesses, negotiating settlements with insurers or defendants, and representing you in civil, disciplinary or criminal proceedings.
Key legal points relevant in Sassuolo reflect the Italian Civil Code and procedural law, with local implementation by courts and professional bodies:
- Types of liability - Contractual vs non-contractual: Liability for professionals often arises from the contract for services. Contractual claims and non-contractual tort claims can follow different rules, including different prescription periods.
- Standard of care: Professionals are judged by the standard of diligence and skill typical of their profession. For highly technical or difficult activities, the law applies a standard that may limit liability to cases of gross negligence in certain circumstances.
- Burden of proof: The claimant must normally prove fault, causal link between the act or omission and the damage, and the amount of damage suffered. Expert reports are commonly used to establish technical issues and causation.
- Prescription periods: Time limits apply to bring claims. As a general rule, contractual claims often have a longer prescription period than tort claims. The precise time limit depends on the legal basis of the claim and when the claimant became aware of the damage and its cause.
- Insurance and third-party payers: Many professionals carry mandatory professional liability insurance. Public health institutions and private clinics may also be defendants. Insurance companies are frequently involved in settlement negotiations.
- Disciplinary proceedings: Separate from civil or criminal cases, the professional order for the relevant profession can open disciplinary procedures that may lead to sanctions, suspension or removal from the register.
- Local institutions and courts: Civil claims arising in Sassuolo are generally handled by the Tribunale di Modena. Criminal complaints are handled by the Procura della Repubblica di Modena. Administrative or regulatory disputes may involve regional bodies such as the TAR Emilia-Romagna or the Azienda USL of Modena for healthcare-related complaints.
Malpractice occurs when a professional fails to meet the standard of care expected in their profession and that failure causes measurable harm. This can be an act or an omission - for example an error in treatment, inadequate advice, failure to meet statutory obligations, or poor workmanship that causes damage.
You may be able to bring claims against the individual professional, the employer or firm, and - in healthcare matters - the hospital or clinic. Liability often depends on the employment or contractual relationship and on whether the act was within the scope of the professional's duties.
There are statutory time limits - prescription periods - for bringing claims. The applicable period depends on whether the claim is based on contract or tort and on the type of damage. Prescription usually begins when the claimant knows the damage and its cause. Because time limits can be decisive, you should consult a lawyer promptly to preserve your rights.
Typical evidence includes medical records, contracts and invoices, correspondence, photographs, expert reports, witness statements and any relevant documents showing loss or expenses. An expert technical or medical opinion is often essential to prove breach of the standard of care and causation.
Many cases are resolved through negotiation or settlement with the professional or their insurer. Alternative dispute resolution - for example mediation or conciliation - can be an efficient option. However, if negotiations fail, a civil suit before the Tribunale may be necessary to obtain compensation.
Yes, if the alleged conduct amounts to a criminal offence - such as serious negligence causing injury or death, or deliberate wrongdoing - you can file a complaint with the police or directly with the Procura della Repubblica. Criminal proceedings are separate from civil compensation claims.
The relevant professional order - for example the Ordine dei Medici, Ordine degli Avvocati, Ordine degli Ingegneri - can receive complaints and open disciplinary proceedings. Disciplinary outcomes can include warnings, fines, suspension or removal from the register. Disciplinary sanctions are independent of civil damages.
Fees vary by lawyer and case complexity. Some lawyers charge hourly rates, others fixed fees for specific tasks, and conditional fee arrangements or success fees may be possible within regulatory limits. Discuss fees and billing arrangements at your first meeting. If you have limited means, you may qualify for legal aid - patrocinio a spese dello Stato.
Compensation aims to restore the injured party to the position they would have been in without the malpractice - this may include medical expenses, lost earnings, future care costs, and compensation for pain and suffering. The amount depends on the extent of the damage, evidence, and legal assessment of causation.
Timelines vary widely. Pre-litigation settlement efforts may take weeks to months. Civil proceedings can take from several months to multiple years depending on case complexity, expert examinations, court backlog and whether appeals are filed. Criminal or disciplinary proceedings have their own timelines.
Useful local and national resources to contact or consult include:
- Tribunale di Modena - for civil litigation and procedural questions.
- Procura della Repubblica di Modena - for criminal complaints.
- Ordine dei Medici Chirurghi e degli Odontoiatri della Provincia di Modena - for medical disciplinary complaints and information.
- Ordine degli Avvocati di Modena - for assistance in finding a lawyer and ethical rules for lawyers.
- Ordine degli Ingegneri, Ordine dei Dottori Commercialisti e degli Esperti Contabili - for complaints about technical or accounting professionals.
- Azienda USL di Modena - for complaints and patient relations in public health facilities.
- Consumer associations - for advice and support in disputes with professionals and service providers.
- Ministry of Justice and national legal information portals - for procedural rules and legal aid information.
If you believe you have suffered professional malpractice, follow these practical steps:
- Preserve evidence: keep medical records, contracts, invoices, prescriptions, emails, photographs and any documents that show the events and your losses.
- Seek a preliminary assessment: consult a lawyer experienced in professional malpractice in the Modena area - many offer an initial consultation to evaluate strength of the case and possible remedies.
- Obtain expert opinions: a technical or medical expert can help establish whether the standard of care was breached and whether the breach caused your damage.
- Notify relevant parties: in some cases, sending a formal notice or a claim to the professional or their insurer starts settlement discussions and preserves your position.
- Consider all pathways: your lawyer will advise on civil claims for compensation, possible criminal complaints, and disciplinary complaints to the professional order, and may explore mediation or settlement before litigation.
- Act promptly: because legal time limits can bar claims, contact a lawyer without unnecessary delay so your rights are protected.
Note - this guide provides general information and not legal advice. For advice tailored to your situation, consult a qualified lawyer in Sassuolo or the Province of Modena.
