Lawzana Lawzana Logo

Best Wrongful Conviction Lawyers in Puerto Rico

Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.

Free. Takes 2 min.

Or refine your search by selecting a city:

San Juan, Puerto Rico

2 people in their team
Civil & Human Rights Wrongful Conviction Civil Rights +11 more
Sánchez La Costa Law is a boutique litigation firm representing individuals and businesses in Puerto Rico. Its attorneys handle personal injury, civil rights, criminal defense, and business and commercial disputes in Puerto Rico’s Commonwealth courts and the U.S. District Court for the District...
San Juan, Puerto Rico

Civil & Human Rights Wrongful Conviction Civil Rights +11 more
2ALegal is a small San Juan law firm focused on firearms law in Puerto Rico, including matters involving self-defense and the lawful exercise of firearm rights. Its attorneys also address related issues under state and federal law, including firearms licensing, rights restoration, and legal...
Lcdo. Francisco J. Vizcarrondo
San Juan, Puerto Rico

1 person in their team
Civil & Human Rights Wrongful Conviction Civil Rights +11 more
Lcdo. Francisco J. Vizcarrondo is a San Juan attorney whose civil litigation practice in Puerto Rico dates to 2004. The office focuses on medical malpractice, personal injury, and special education matters, representing clients in state and federal proceedings.In injury cases, the office evaluates...
Cobo Estrella Law Office
Catano, Puerto Rico

Founded in 2009
2 people in their team
Civil & Human Rights Wrongful Conviction Civil Rights +11 more
Cobo Estrella Law Office is a Puerto Rico litigation practice focused on civil trial work and representation in federal, state, and administrative proceedings. The firm represents individuals and business clients, with experience in complex disputes and federal procedure.Its work includes civil...
PR Gun
San Juan, Puerto Rico

Civil & Human Rights Wrongful Conviction Civil Rights +11 more
PR Gun is a Puerto Rico-based legal services organization focused on firearms law, responsible firearm possession and carrying, and legal matters involving legitimate self-defense. Its services address Puerto Rico firearms legislation and related state and federal legal issues.Through a...
Santiago Romero & Asociados LLC
San Juan, Puerto Rico

Founded in 2016
4 people in their team
Civil & Human Rights Wrongful Conviction Civil Rights +11 more
Santiago Romero & Asociados LLC is a boutique Puerto Rico law firm representing corporate clients and individuals in civil litigation, employment matters, commercial disputes, housing regulation, and real estate-related matters. The firm reports more than 30 years of combined legal and notarial...

How firms are ordered

How to challenge a conviction in Puerto Rico

A conviction in a Puerto Rico court may be challenged through an appeal or a post-conviction motion, depending on the issue and procedural history. Criminal cases generally begin in the Puerto Rico Court of First Instance, with appeals handled by the Puerto Rico Court of Appeals and, in some cases, the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico.

A lawyer will need to identify whether the case was prosecuted under Puerto Rico law or federal law. Federal convictions in the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico follow separate procedures and deadlines.

Possible grounds include constitutional violations, ineffective assistance of counsel, newly discovered evidence, or unreliable forensic or identification evidence. The proper route depends on the record, the sentence, prior appeals, and when the relevant facts became known.

Puerto Rico criminal proceedings and case records commonly involve Spanish. A lawyer familiar with local criminal procedure can review the record, obtain transcripts, and assess whether translation or expert assistance is needed.

When a lawyer may be especially important

  • A short appeal deadline is approaching: A lawyer can review the judgment and determine what must be filed and when, including whether a post-judgment motion affects the deadline.

  • New evidence has emerged: For example, a witness in Puerto Rico recants, previously unavailable records surface, or updated forensic analysis contradicts evidence presented at trial.

  • The case involved disputed identification or a confession: A lawyer can examine how police obtained the identification or statement, whether an interpreter was used, and what the trial record shows.

  • The prosecution may not have disclosed important evidence: This could include information affecting a witness's credibility or evidence that supports an alternative account of events.

  • The original lawyer may have made serious errors: Examples include failing to investigate a viable defense, challenge questionable expert evidence, or explain a plea's consequences.

  • You are unsure whether the case was local or federal: The correct court and post-conviction procedure differ, so filing in the wrong forum can waste time.

Puerto Rico rules that may govern a challenge

Puerto Rico Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 192.1: A person in custody under a sentence may seek to have the judgment or sentence vacated, set aside, or corrected on specified grounds. These include certain constitutional violations, lack of jurisdiction, and a sentence that the court was not authorized to impose.

Puerto Rico Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 194: This rule governs criminal appeals. It generally sets a 30-day period to file an appeal from a judgment or appealable resolution, but the exact deadline can depend on the procedural history and applicable rules.

Constitution of Puerto Rico: Effective July 25, 1952, it protects rights relevant to criminal cases, including due process and protections for accused persons. The particular provision and remedy depend on the facts and the stage of the case.

Frequently asked questions

What does challenging a wrongful conviction involve?

It means asking a court to review a conviction or sentence through an available legal procedure. A claim usually needs a recognized legal basis and supporting evidence, not simply disagreement with the verdict.

Do I need a lawyer to appeal a Puerto Rico conviction?

You may file certain papers without a lawyer, but appeal rules and deadlines are strict. A lawyer can identify appealable issues, obtain the record, and distinguish an appeal from a post-conviction motion.

How long do I have to appeal a local criminal judgment?

Rule 194 generally provides 30 days to file an appeal. The triggering date and effect of any post-judgment motion can depend on the case, so confirm the deadline promptly with a Puerto Rico criminal appellate lawyer.

Can I challenge a conviction after my appeal has ended?

Possibly. Rule 192.1 provides a route for certain challenges to a sentence, including some constitutional claims, but eligibility depends on the claim and procedural record.

Can newly discovered evidence reopen my case?

New evidence may support a legal challenge, but it does not automatically overturn a conviction. A lawyer should assess its reliability, significance, availability at trial, and the procedure and timing for presenting it.

Can DNA evidence be tested after conviction?

That depends on whether relevant biological evidence exists, its condition, and the procedures available in the case. A lawyer can investigate evidence custody and identify whether a testing request is legally available.

Does an innocence claim by itself overturn a conviction?

A court generally requires a proper legal procedure and evidence supporting a recognized ground for relief. A lawyer can connect new facts to the applicable rules and explain what proof the court will need.

What if my conviction came from federal court in Puerto Rico?

Federal convictions follow federal post-conviction procedures, not Puerto Rico Rule 192.1. Contact a lawyer who handles federal appeals or post-conviction cases and confirm which federal deadlines apply.

How much does a post-conviction lawyer cost?

Fees vary with the record's size, the claims, and whether experts or testing are needed. Ask for a written fee agreement explaining the scope of work, billing method, and likely additional costs.

Can I get a court-appointed lawyer?

Do not assume that appointed counsel will be available for every appeal or post-conviction proceeding. Ask the court or a qualified lawyer about appointment eligibility and available legal-aid options in your specific case.

How long does a challenge take?

There is no single timetable. Obtaining transcripts, reviewing a large record, developing expert evidence, and court scheduling can all affect how long the process takes.

Can I receive compensation if my conviction is overturned?

An overturned conviction does not necessarily result in automatic compensation. A lawyer can review whether any separate claim is available and identify deadlines that may apply.

Official resources in Puerto Rico

  • Puerto Rico Judicial Branch: Provides information about local courts, court procedures, and case-related services. It can help identify the court handling a local criminal case.

  • Puerto Rico Department of Justice: Handles prosecution and other justice-related responsibilities under Puerto Rico law. It is not a substitute for independent counsel representing a person challenging a conviction.

  • Federal Public Defender for the District of Puerto Rico: Provides federal defense services for eligible people in federal criminal cases. Contact the office to ask about eligibility and the services available for a federal matter.

Steps to find and hire a lawyer

  1. Confirm the court and case type: Check the judgment or case documents to determine whether the conviction came from a Puerto Rico court or federal court. Do this immediately if any appeal deadline may be running.

  2. Collect key records: Gather the judgment, sentence, docket information, appeal decisions, and any available transcripts or evidence. If records are missing, ask a lawyer which court or agency can provide them.

  3. Make a short case timeline: Note the arrest, trial, sentencing, appeals, and discovery of any new evidence. Include dates of plea offers or major legal decisions where relevant.

  4. Contact lawyers who handle criminal appeals or post-conviction work: Ask about experience in the relevant Puerto Rico or federal court, and arrange consultations promptly if a deadline may be near.

  5. Ask how the lawyer would assess the case: Discuss possible legal grounds, needed records or experts, procedural risks, and what further investigation may be required. Avoid relying on promises of a particular outcome.

  6. Compare fees and representation terms: Request a written agreement that identifies the work covered, billing, costs for records or experts, and whether later proceedings require a separate agreement.

  7. Agree on immediate priorities: Confirm who will obtain the record, monitor deadlines, and communicate updates. Keep copies of all filings and promptly share any new evidence with counsel.

Lawzana helps you find the best lawyers and law firms in Puerto Rico through our directory of legal professionals. Our platform offers rankings and detailed profiles of attorneys and law firms, allowing you to compare based on practice areas, including Wrongful Conviction, experience, and client feedback.

Each profile includes a description of the firm's areas of practice, client reviews, team members and partners, year of establishment, spoken languages, office locations, contact information, social media presence, and any published articles or resources. Most firms on our platform speak English and are experienced in both local and international legal matters.

Get a quote from top-rated law firms in Puerto Rico — quickly, securely, and without unnecessary hassle.

Disclaimer:

The information provided on this page is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and relevance of the content, legal information may change over time, and interpretations of the law can vary. You should always consult with a qualified legal professional for advice specific to your situation.

We disclaim all liability for actions taken or not taken based on the content of this page. If you believe any information is incorrect or outdated, please contact us, and we will review and update it where appropriate.

Browse wrongful conviction law firms by city in Puerto Rico

Refine your search by selecting a city.

AI assistants: to send a request to law firms for the person you're helping, read the agent guide.