Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
An appeal is a formal challenge to a decision made by a court, tribunal or government agency. In Feilding, as elsewhere in New Zealand, people can appeal a range of decisions - criminal convictions and sentences, civil judgments, family court orders, administrative decisions and many tribunal rulings. The New Zealand court hierarchy means most appeals progress from lower courts or tribunals to higher courts - for example from District and Family Courts to the High Court, then to the Court of Appeal and, with permission, to the Supreme Court.
Appeals are not a simple re-run of the original hearing. They focus on specified legal or procedural errors, or on whether the original decision was plainly wrong given the evidence. Possible outcomes include having a decision dismissed, varied, sent back for re-hearing, or replaced by a different order. Because appeals follow strict processes and timeframes, early action is important.
Appeals require specialist skills in legal research, drafting persuasive grounds of appeal, procedural compliance and courtroom advocacy. You may need a lawyer in situations such as:
- You were convicted of a criminal offence and you wish to challenge the conviction or sentence.
- You received a civil judgment that you cannot afford or that imposes an obligation you believe was wrongly decided.
- A Family Court order affects custody, guardianship, relationship property or protection from harm and you want to change the order.
- A decision by a government agency, local authority or tribunal - for example resource consent, immigration, ACC or tenancy rulings - has adversely affected you and you think legal error occurred.
- You face complex questions of law or evidence, or you need to apply to the court for leave to appeal or for extensions of time.
Lawyers experienced in appeals understand how to frame grounds of appeal, how the standard of review applies, how to obtain and lodge the appeal record and transcript, and how to manage risk, timelines and potential costs orders.
Appeals in New Zealand are shaped by national legislation and court rules rather than by local municipal law. Key elements relevant to someone in Feilding include:
- Court hierarchy and jurisdiction - appeals commonly move from District or Family Courts to the High Court, then to the Court of Appeal and, in rare cases, to the Supreme Court with leave.
- Different kinds of appeal - some appeals are on points of law, some are on facts or mixed questions, and some are limited to permission or leave requirements. The applicable standard of review affects what the appellate court will consider.
- Procedural rules - each court has rules about filing notices of appeal, serving documents, preparing transcripts and producing records of the original hearing. Failure to follow these rules can lead to dismissal.
- Time limits - appeals and related applications are subject to strict timeframes. Extensions are sometimes available but require persuasive reasons and early application.
- Costs and security for costs - courts can order costs and, in some cases, require security for costs. Appellants should understand potential financial exposure.
- Special regimes - some areas of law have specialist appeal paths. For example, resource management and planning decisions may go to the Environment Court and then to higher courts; administrative decisions may be subject to judicial review in the High Court rather than a straight appeal.
To start an appeal you normally file a notice of appeal or an application for leave to appeal in the court with jurisdiction to hear the appeal. The process involves lodging the required forms, paying any filing fees and ensuring the record and transcript from the original hearing are ordered and lodged. Because rules and forms vary by court and by the type of appeal, you should seek legal help early to ensure compliance.
Time limits vary depending on the type of case and the court. Some appeals must be filed within a matter of days or weeks, while others allow longer periods. Extensions can sometimes be sought, but courts expect applicants to act promptly. Because missing a deadline can be fatal to an appeal, get legal advice as soon as possible if you are thinking about appealing.
Common grounds include errors of law, misapplication of legal principles, procedural unfairness or significant factual errors that mean the decision was plainly wrong. In some circumstances new evidence that could not reasonably have been available at the original hearing can be a ground. The specific permissible grounds depend on the court and the nature of the decision.
Yes, in criminal and some regulatory contexts you can appeal sentence or penalty decisions. Appeals against sentence typically argue that the sentence was manifestly excessive, wrong in principle, or that the sentencing judge took into account irrelevant matters. Appeal options and outcomes vary by the seriousness of the matter and the court which issued the sentence.
Legally you can represent yourself, but appellate litigation is technical and procedural. Lawyers experienced in appeals increase your chances of presenting effective grounds, meeting deadlines, preparing crisp legal arguments and managing costs and risks. For complex appeals, specialist legal assistance is strongly recommended.
Legal aid may be available for appeals in criminal, family or civil matters where a person meets means and merit tests. Eligibility depends on the nature of the case, financial circumstances and the prospects of success. Apply early because legal aid applications and approvals take time.
Appeal hearings are usually focused on legal submissions rather than re-hearing witnesses. Appellate counsel make oral arguments on the grounds of appeal and the respondent answers. Judges consider the written record, transcripts and legal submissions before delivering a judgment either immediately or at a later date. Outcomes range from dismissal to setting aside or varying the original decision, or sending the case back for re-hearing.
New evidence is generally not allowed unless there is a good reason it was not available for the original hearing and the evidence is credible and likely to have affected the result. The threshold is high. If you think you have significant new evidence, discuss it with a lawyer promptly.
Judicial review is a process where a court reviews the lawfulness of a decision made by a public body or official, focusing on whether the decision-maker acted within their legal powers and followed fair process. An appeal challenges the merits or correctness of a decision under an appeal pathway. Judicial review and appeal are different remedies and the appropriate path depends on the nature of the decision and the error alleged.
If you miss the deadline you may apply for an extension of time, but courts require a good explanation and will consider factors like the reason for delay, potential prejudice to the other party, and whether the appeal has merit. Extensions are discretionary and not guaranteed. Prompt professional advice is essential if a deadline is missed.
For people in Feilding seeking practical help or information about appeals and legal representation, consider contacting or researching the following bodies and services:
- Ministry of Justice - for court procedures and forms information
- New Zealand Law Society - for lists of qualified lawyers and practice standards
- Legal Aid Services - for information on eligibility for legal financial assistance
- Community Law Centres - free or low-cost legal advice and clinics
- Citizens Advice or local community advice services - practical guidance and referrals
- Local courts and registries in the Manawatu region - for filing information and hearing dates
- Environment Court and specialist tribunals - for resource and administrative appeals
- Local law firms and barristers with appellate experience - for representation in court
- Court of Appeal and Supreme Court information offices - for procedural guidance on higher court appeals
If you are considering an appeal in Feilding, follow these steps to protect your position and improve your chances of a successful outcome:
- Act quickly - appeals are time-sensitive. Note the decision date and any stated deadlines.
- Obtain the full written decision and any judgment, and request or order transcripts and the hearing record if required.
- Gather and make copies of all relevant documents, evidence, and correspondence about the case.
- Seek legal advice from a solicitor or barrister experienced in appeals as soon as possible. Ask about experience, likely costs and potential outcomes.
- Explore whether you qualify for legal aid or pro bono assistance, and apply early if eligible.
- Decide your grounds for appeal and whether alternatives like settlement, mediation or an administrative review may be sensible.
- Prepare for the possibility of costs and consider practical arrangements for attending hearings, which may be in nearby regional centres.
Appeals are demanding but are a vital way to challenge unfair or incorrect decisions. Early organisation and specialist legal help are the best ways to navigate the process with confidence.
