Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
An appeal is a legal process that asks a higher court to review a decision made by a trial court. In Palm Desert, appeals from cases filed in the Riverside County Superior Court follow California appellate procedure and are decided by the California Courts of Appeal and, potentially, the California Supreme Court. If a case began in federal court, appellate review is handled by the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Appellate courts generally review the trial record for legal errors or procedural mistakes - they do not hold new trials or accept new evidence. Appellate practice is governed by state and federal rules that set strict deadlines, formatting requirements, and procedures for preparing and filing the record, briefs, and any request for oral argument.
Appeals are legal and procedural exercises that rely on making precise legal arguments, preserving issues for review at trial, and assembling an adequate record. Common reasons to hire an appellate lawyer include:
- You lost at trial and want to challenge the legal basis for the judgment or sentence.
- A court granted or denied a dispositive motion such as summary judgment, dismissal, or a motion to suppress evidence.
- An important evidentiary ruling or jury instruction went against you and you want to argue it was legally incorrect.
- You need help determining whether an issue was properly preserved for appeal or whether a post-judgment motion is required first.
- You need help requesting and preparing trial transcripts, preparing the record on appeal, and drafting appellate briefs that explain the applicable standard of review and relevant case law.
- You are seeking a stay of enforcement of a judgment - for example, to stop a sale, lien enforcement, or collection while an appeal is pending - which often involves posting a bond and complex motion practice.
Appellate lawyers understand standards of review, persuasive legal writing, and procedural traps. Even when appealing pro se, early consultation with a lawyer can clarify merits, deadlines, and required steps.
Key aspects of appeals that are particularly relevant for Palm Desert residents include the following:
- Jurisdiction - Most state-law appeals from Palm Desert cases in Riverside County go first to the California Court of Appeal. Federal appeals from district court decisions go to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
- Deadlines - Deadlines are strict. In California civil cases, a notice of appeal is generally due within 60 days after service of the clerk's notice of entry of judgment, or within 180 days after entry of the judgment if no notice of entry was served. Federal civil appeals normally require a notice of appeal within 30 days of the district court's entry of judgment. Different timelines apply for criminal matters and special types of petitions. Missing a deadline usually forecloses the appeal.
- The record - Appellate courts decide based on the trial court record. That record includes the clerk's papers, exhibits, and transcripts of hearings or trial. You must request transcripts early and pay for them unless a fee waiver or other relief applies. If the record is incomplete, an appellate remedy may be limited.
- Standards of review - Appellate courts use different standards depending on the issue. Questions of law are often reviewed de novo - meaning the appellate court gives no deference to the trial court. Findings of fact are usually reviewed for substantial evidence. Discretionary decisions by the trial court may be reviewed for abuse of discretion. Understanding the correct standard is critical to framing arguments.
- Small claims and limited matters - Some small claims and limited-jurisdiction cases have different appeal routes. For example, small claims appeals are often heard at the superior court as a trial de novo rather than as a traditional appeal on the record.
- Local rules and forms - Riverside County Superior Court and the appellate courts have local rules and filing procedures. The clerk's office in Riverside County can assist with filing and procedural questions, but legal advice requires a lawyer.
An appeal is a legal review of a trial court's decision by a higher court looking for legal error in the record. A new trial is a proceeding in the trial court that reexamines facts and evidence. Appeals focus on legal mistakes, not on re-litigating witness credibility or introducing new evidence.
Timelines vary. In California civil cases the notice of appeal is typically due within 60 days after service of the clerk's notice of entry of judgment, or within 180 days after entry of judgment if no notice is served. Federal civil appeals generally require a notice of appeal within 30 days of the judgment. Criminal appeals and special writs have different deadlines. Check the applicable rules immediately and consult a lawyer if you are near a deadline.
No. Appeals are based on the trial court record. New evidence is not permitted unless there is a narrow statutory or equitable route that allows supplementation of the record - which is rare. If new evidence is critical, you may need to seek relief in the trial court first.
It is not required to have a lawyer, but appeals are highly technical and involve strict procedural requirements. Most people benefit from an attorney who specializes in appellate work. An appellate lawyer can evaluate the merits, preserve issues, prepare the record, and write persuasive briefs.
Costs vary widely. Expect filing fees, the cost of preparing and copying the record, reporter transcript fees, and attorney fees. Complex appeals with multiple transcripts and lengthy briefing are more expensive. Fee waiver or in forma pauperis status may be available in limited circumstances for those who cannot pay.
Typical steps include filing a notice of appeal, obtaining and assembling the trial court record and transcripts, preparing and filing opening, respondent, and reply briefs, possibly requesting oral argument, and awaiting the appellate decision. Some appeals also include motions for stays or bonds to preserve the status quo while the appeal proceeds.
An appellate court can affirm the lower court judgment, reverse it in whole or in part, remand the case for further proceedings, modify the judgment, or order other equitable relief. The court can also dismiss the appeal if it lacks jurisdiction or if procedural requirements are not met.
Sometimes. You may seek a stay of enforcement from the trial court or the appellate court. In civil cases this commonly requires posting a supersedeas bond or other security. Whether a stay is granted depends on statutory rules and judicial discretion. Ask an attorney quickly, because the process and bond requirements take time.
Standard of review determines how much deference the appellate court gives to the trial court's decision. For questions of law the review is often de novo - the appellate court reviews independently. For factual findings the review is usually deferential - substantial evidence must support the finding. The applicable standard shapes how you argue the appeal and what relief is realistic.
Many errors must be preserved by timely objection or motion at trial. Failure to preserve an objection can limit appellate review to whether the error was a manifest miscarriage of justice or constitutes ineffective assistance of counsel in criminal cases. Consult an attorney promptly to determine if any exceptions apply.
Below are types of resources and organizations that can assist with appeals or point you to appellate information in Riverside County and California:
- Riverside County Superior Court - clerk's office and self-help resources for procedure and filing requirements.
- California Court of Appeal - appellate rules and local procedures for the appropriate district.
- California Supreme Court - final state-level appellate authority.
- United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit - for federal appeals arising from district courts in the region.
- California Courts - Self-Help and Appellate Practice pages - general guidance on appeals and forms.
- State Bar of California - lawyer referral services and information on finding an appellate specialist.
- Local bar associations and legal aid organizations - for referrals, low-cost assistance, or pro bono help. Examples include county bar associations and nonprofit legal services that serve Riverside County residents.
- LawHelp and statewide legal aid directories - to find resources by topic and income eligibility.
If you are considering an appeal in Palm Desert, follow these practical steps:
- Act quickly - identify and mark filing deadlines immediately. Missing a deadline usually ends an appeal.
- Preserve the record - ensure transcripts and clerk's record are requested and paid for on time, or seek a fee waiver if eligible.
- Consult an appellate attorney for an early merits assessment - a lawyer can tell you if you have viable issues and advise on the best approach.
- Consider post-judgment motions first - in some cases a motion for new trial or reconsideration can fix errors without appeal or preserve issues for appeal.
- Plan financially - gather funds for filing fees, transcripts, and counsel, or explore fee waivers and low-cost assistance options.
- If enforcement is imminent, ask about emergency relief - a stay or supersedeas bond may be necessary to prevent collection or execution.
Getting professional advice early will help you understand realistic outcomes and avoid procedural pitfalls. If you do not know where to start, contact the local court clerk for procedural information and the State Bar or a local bar association for a referral to an appellate specialist.
