Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
Bad faith insurance law covers situations in which an insurance company fails to handle a claim fairly, reasonably, or in accordance with the insurance contract and applicable law. In the United States, insurance regulation and bad-faith standards are primarily set by state law. That means if you live in Beverly, United States, the state where Beverly is located governs the rules, procedures, and remedies that apply. Common examples of bad-faith conduct include unreasonable denial of a valid claim, unreasonable delay in investigating or paying a claim, lowball settlement offers, failure to properly defend an insured under a liability policy, and misrepresentation of policy terms or coverage.
Bad-faith claims can be brought either as a contract claim for breach of the insurance policy or as a tort claim seeking additional damages when the insurer acts in bad faith. Remedies may include payment of the policy benefits, consequential damages, attorney fees in some cases, and, in certain jurisdictions, punitive damages when the insurer’s conduct is particularly willful or reckless.
Insurance disputes often involve complex legal issues, technical policy language, and tight deadlines. A lawyer can help you evaluate whether an insurer’s actions rise to the level of bad faith and can guide you through the steps needed to preserve your rights. Common situations where you may need legal help include:
- Your insurer denies a claim despite clear coverage under the policy.
- The insurer delays investigation or payment for an unreasonable period, leaving you without funds to repair damage or pay medical bills.
- You receive a low settlement offer that does not cover your damages or future needs.
- Your insurer refuses to defend you in a liability suit or provides a reservation-of-rights letter that affects your position.
- The insurer misrepresents policy terms, cancels your policy without proper notice, or rescinds coverage after a claim is made.
- The claim involves complicated coverage issues such as business interruption, bad-faith denials in health or disability claims, disputes with an employer-sponsored plan subject to ERISA, or large commercial claims.
Because insurance is regulated at the state level, the most relevant laws and rules for bad-faith claims in Beverly will be the statutes, regulations, and court decisions of the state where Beverly is located. Key local-law aspects to understand include:
- State Insurance Code and Unfair Claims Practices Act - Many states have statutes that list prohibited practices by insurers, such as misrepresenting policy provisions, failing to acknowledge or act promptly on communications, and failing to adopt reasonable standards for investigation.
- Common-law bad-faith tort - In many states, insureds can sue insurers in tort for bad faith. The legal standard varies by state - some require proof that the insurer knew the denial was wrongful or acted with reckless disregard, while others apply an objective standard focused on whether the insurer had a reasonable basis.
- Statute of limitations - Time limits for filing suit vary by state and may differ for contract claims and tort claims. It is essential to know and follow the applicable deadlines.
- Remedies - Available remedies vary. They commonly include contract damages for benefits due, consequential damages caused by the insurer’s conduct, attorney fees in some cases, and punitive damages in states that allow them for particularly egregious conduct.
- Administrative remedies - Most states allow consumers to file complaints with the state Department of Insurance. The department can investigate, mediate, and take enforcement action, but it cannot typically award damages like a court.
- Alternative dispute resolution and policy provisions - Many policies contain appraisal clauses, arbitration requirements, or exhaustion conditions that affect how disputes must be pursued. Some states limit the enforceability of certain arbitration or mandatory forum clauses.
- ERISA preemption - If a claim involves an employer-sponsored benefit plan governed by ERISA, the federal statute may preempt state bad-faith claims and limit remedies to those available under ERISA, which often do not include punitive damages.
A bad-faith insurance claim alleges that an insurer handled a claim unreasonably, dishonestly, or with improper motive, beyond a simple disagreement over coverage. Bad-faith can be a separate tort claim or arise alongside a breach-of-contract claim to recover additional damages caused by the insurer’s wrongful conduct.
An insurer can legitimately deny a claim if the claim is excluded under the policy or if the insured fails to satisfy a policy condition. Bad-faith occurs when the insurer lacks a reasonable basis for denial or delay, misrepresents facts or policy language, fails to investigate, or otherwise acts in a way that is unfair or deceptive.
Contact a lawyer as soon as you suspect the insurer is acting unreasonably - for example, after a denial without explanation, repeated unexplained delays, a lowball offer, or a refusal to defend a liability suit. Early legal involvement helps preserve evidence, meet deadlines, and pursue administrative remedies if appropriate.
Evidence can include the insurance policy, claim file documents, written communications, notes of phone calls, photographs, invoices, repair estimates, medical records, denials or reservation-of-rights letters, expert reports, and any proof that the insurer ignored or misrepresented facts. Records showing internal delays or a pattern of similar conduct may be especially important.
Time limits depend on state law and whether you bring contract or tort claims. Some states use the standard statute of limitations for contracts, while others have different periods for torts. There may also be administrative deadlines for appeals or complaints to the state insurance department. Consult a lawyer promptly to determine applicable deadlines.
Some states and some statutes allow recovery of attorney fees to a prevailing insured, while others do not. In many bad-faith cases, courts award attorney fees when the insured prevails on certain claims. A lawyer can advise whether fee-shifting is available in your jurisdiction and how that affects how your case might be handled.
Filing a complaint with the state Department of Insurance is often a good step. The regulator can investigate and may help resolve disputes or impose sanctions. However, administrative investigations do not usually provide monetary awards to consumers, so a separate lawsuit may still be necessary for compensation.
If your claim is governed by ERISA, federal law may preempt state bad-faith causes of action. ERISA typically limits remedies to plan benefits plus, in some cases, plan-related relief and attorney fees under specific statutes. ERISA cases follow different rules and strict timelines, so seek counsel experienced in ERISA matters quickly.
Claims against agents or brokers involve different legal theories, such as negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, or negligent misrepresentation. Whether you can sue an agent depends on the facts and local law. Bad-faith torts typically target the insurer, but agents can be liable in appropriate circumstances.
Successful bad-faith claims can result in payment of the policy benefits, consequential damages caused by the insurer’s conduct, recovery of attorney fees in some cases, and punitive damages in jurisdictions that permit them for particularly egregious behavior. The exact remedy depends on the state law and the facts of the case.
To learn more or get assistance you can contact the following types of organizations and offices in your state and local area:
- State Department of Insurance - handles consumer complaints and enforces insurance regulations.
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners - provides consumer guides and state contact information.
- State or local bar association - can provide lawyer referral services and lists of attorneys with insurance litigation experience.
- Legal aid organizations - may offer free or low-cost assistance for qualifying consumers.
- Consumer protection offices - state attorney general consumer divisions may take enforcement action against unfair practices.
- Local law libraries and court self-help centers - can help you research statutes, regulations, and case law if you are handling matters yourself.
- Financial or regulatory ombudsmen - some industries and plans offer ombudsman services for disputes.
If you believe you have a bad-faith insurance issue, take these practical steps right away:
- Preserve all documents - keep the policy, claim numbers, all letters and emails, notes of phone calls with dates and times, estimates, bills, photos, and any relevant paperwork.
- Make written requests - ask the insurer in writing for a thorough explanation of any denial, delay, or low offer and request the complete claim file if permitted under state law.
- File an internal appeal - follow the insurer’s appeal or reconsideration process within required timeframes.
- Consider filing a complaint with the state Department of Insurance - this can trigger an investigation and sometimes lead to resolution.
- Consult a lawyer experienced in insurance bad-faith litigation - schedule a consultation to discuss your options, potential remedies, and deadlines. Ask about experience, recent results, likely strategy, and fee structure.
- Act promptly - statutes of limitations and procedural requirements can bar claims if you wait too long. Early legal counsel helps protect evidence and preserves your claims.
Getting the right help early improves the chance of recovering what you are owed and holding an insurer accountable for wrongful conduct. If you are unsure where to start, a consultation with an attorney who focuses on insurance disputes will clarify your rights and the best path forward.
