Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
Bad faith insurance law addresses situations where an insurance company fails to act fairly toward its insured. In Nashville, which is in Davidson County, Tennessee, bad faith claims can arise when an insurer unreasonably denies a valid claim, delays payment without justification, fails to investigate properly, lowballs a settlement, or otherwise violates the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing. These claims may be pursued in state court or handled administratively through the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance. This guide explains the basics, the common scenarios that lead people to seek legal help, the local legal framework, frequently asked questions, and practical next steps.
Insurance disputes can be complex, technical, and time sensitive. You may need a lawyer when:
- Your insurer denies a claim that you believe is covered under your policy without a reasonable explanation.
- The insurer delays investigation or payment for no clear, lawful reason and you suffer financial harm as a result.
- The insurer offers a settlement that is clearly insufficient to cover your documented losses or medical costs.
- The insurer refuses to defend or indemnify you under a liability policy when a third party makes a covered claim.
- You are facing a pattern of unfair treatment or suspect the insurer engaged in fraudulent or bad-faith practices.
A lawyer helps by evaluating your policy and claim, preserving evidence, advising on statutory and case law that applies in Tennessee, communicating with the insurer, pursuing administrative remedies, and, if necessary, representing you in court to recover benefits, interest, attorney fees, and potentially punitive damages.
Tennessee law governs insurance matters in Nashville. Key local and state aspects to understand include:
- Duty of good faith and fair dealing: Tennessee recognizes that insurers owe insureds a duty to handle claims reasonably. A bad faith claim typically requires showing the insurer lacked a reasonable basis for its conduct or acted with knowledge of the lack of a reasonable basis.
- Statutory regulation: Tennessee enforces statutes and regulations that prohibit unfair claims settlement practices. The Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance administers consumer protections and investigates complaints against insurers.
- Remedies and damages: Remedies may include recovery of the policy benefits owed, consequential damages arising from the insurer's conduct, interest, and in some cases punitive damages and attorney fees depending on the facts and applicable law. The availability and scope of these remedies depend on whether the claim is framed as breach of contract, tort bad faith, or based on statutory violations.
- Administrative options: You can file a complaint with the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance. The Department can investigate and may order corrective action, but it does not replace private litigation in many cases.
- Court process and venue: Bad faith lawsuits are commonly brought in Tennessee state court in the county where the insured resides or where the policy issue arose. In Nashville that typically means Davidson County courts. There are procedural rules and filing deadlines to observe.
- Deadlines and statute of limitations: Timelines vary by the legal theory used. Contract claims, tort claims, and statutory claims can have different limitation periods. Because deadlines may be short and may run from different triggering events, consult an attorney quickly to preserve your rights.
Bad faith refers to insurer conduct that is unreasonable, unfair, or done with knowledge of a lack of reasonable basis. Examples include denying a clearly covered claim, failing to investigate, misrepresenting policy provisions, or intentionally delaying payment to coerce a low settlement.
A denied claim alone may be a breach of contract if benefits are owed. A bad faith claim adds a claim for wrongful insurer conduct beyond mere contract breach. It requires proof the insurer acted unreasonably or with wrongful intent, and it may allow additional damages beyond the policy benefits.
Helpful evidence includes the insurance policy, claim correspondence, internal insurer communications if available, recorded denials or delay notices, contemporaneous photos of damage, repair estimates, medical records, timelines showing unreasonable delay, and any independent expert reports. Preserve all documents and communications.
Yes. The Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance accepts consumer complaints about insurance companies. The Department can investigate and may take enforcement action, but an agency complaint does not substitute for a private lawsuit in many cases.
The time limit depends on the legal theory you use. Contract claims and tort claims have different statutes of limitations. Because the exact deadline can vary and may be triggered by different events, you should seek legal advice promptly to avoid missing a deadline.
In some circumstances, prevailing plaintiffs can recover attorney fees, particularly when statutes authorize fee-shifting or when the court finds the insurer acted in bad faith. Whether fees are available depends on the claim, the evidence, and applicable law.
Possible damages include the policy benefits owed, consequential damages that flow from the insurer's conduct, interest, punitive damages in egregious cases, and attorney fees when authorized. The scope of recoverable damages depends on facts and legal theory.
Not always. Many disputes are resolved through negotiation, mediation, appraisal, or settlement. However, if settlement efforts fail, litigation may be necessary. An attorney can evaluate whether alternative dispute resolution is appropriate and can represent you in negotiations or court.
Many insurance attorneys handle bad faith cases on contingency fee basis, which means they receive a percentage of any recovery and charge no fee if they do not win. Fee arrangements vary, so ask about fee structure, costs, and what portion of the recovery you can expect to receive after fees and expenses.
Look for an attorney with specific experience in insurance litigation, a track record with bad faith cases, familiarity with Tennessee law and Davidson County courts, good client references, transparent fee arrangements, and the resources to pursue litigation if needed. An initial consultation will help you evaluate fit and strategy.
Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance - Consumer Services Division: Accepts insurance complaints, provides information on consumer rights, and explains the complaint process.
Tennessee Bar Association - Find a Lawyer and consumer resources on choosing an attorney and understanding basic legal procedures.
Legal Aid Society of Middle Tennessee and the Cumberlands - May provide assistance to qualifying low-income consumers who face insurance disputes or need legal guidance.
Nashville Bar Association - Local referral services and lawyer directories for residents of Davidson County.
National Association of Insurance Commissioners - Offers consumer information and state-level insurance regulatory guidance that can help you understand industry standards and practices.
Local courthouse - Davidson County civil court clerk can provide procedural information about filing a lawsuit and local court rules.
1. Preserve documents and create a timeline: Immediately save your insurance policy, all communications with the insurer, claim forms, photos, repair estimates, medical bills, and any other records. Write a clear timeline of events showing when you reported the claim, what responses you received, and any damages or expenses you incurred.
2. Contact the insurer in writing: If you have not already done so, send a concise written request for explanation or payment and keep copies. A demand letter from you or your attorney can sometimes prompt resolution.
3. File an administrative complaint if appropriate: If the insurer’s conduct appears to violate consumer protection laws or settlement practices, consider filing a complaint with the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance while you pursue other options.
4. Seek a legal consultation promptly: Because deadlines can be strict, speak with an attorney experienced in Tennessee bad faith and insurance disputes as soon as possible. Bring your policy, claim file, correspondence, and other documentation to the meeting.
5. Consider alternative dispute resolution: Discuss with your lawyer whether mediation or appraisal is suitable. These options can be faster and less expensive than litigation, but they may not be appropriate in every case.
6. Prepare for litigation if needed: If negotiations fail, your attorney can advise on filing suit, pursuing discovery to obtain insurer records, and presenting evidence to prove bad faith.
Remember, this guide is informational and does not constitute legal advice. For an assessment of your specific situation and the best course of action, consult a licensed Tennessee attorney experienced in insurance law.
