Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
Legal malpractice refers to professional negligence or other wrongful conduct by an attorney that causes harm to a client. In McAllen, which is in Texas, legal malpractice claims arise when a client believes their attorney failed to provide the competent representation expected under the attorney-client relationship. Common examples include missed filing deadlines, conflicts of interest, poor communication, inadequate investigation or preparation, improper handling of client funds, and settlement or litigation decisions made without client authorization.
Legal malpractice is distinct from an ethical or disciplinary complaint. A disciplinary complaint asks the State Bar to investigate and discipline lawyer misconduct, while a malpractice lawsuit seeks monetary compensation for losses caused by the attorney's actions. Both paths can be pursued, but they have different goals, procedures, and standards of proof.
If you believe you have suffered harm because your attorney acted negligently, you may need a lawyer who specializes in legal malpractice. Reasons to consult a malpractice attorney include:
- Assessing whether the attorney breached the standard of care that a reasonably competent lawyer would have provided under similar circumstances.
- Determining whether you can prove causation - that the lawyer's mistake actually caused your financial loss - and calculating damages.
- Deciding whether to pursue a civil malpractice claim, pursue fee arbitration, or file an ethics complaint with the State Bar.
- Handling complex procedural issues such as statute of limitations, tolling, indemnity, or whether the underlying legal matter must be resolved before a malpractice claim can proceed.
- Negotiating settlements with the former attorney or the attorney's malpractice insurer, or taking the claim to court if necessary.
Legal malpractice in McAllen is governed primarily by Texas law - statutes, case law, and professional rules that apply statewide. Key local legal considerations include:
- Elements of a malpractice claim: To succeed, a plaintiff typically must prove that an attorney-client relationship existed, the attorney breached the applicable standard of care, the breach proximately caused injury, and the client suffered recoverable damages.
- Theories of recovery: Actions commonly proceed under legal negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, or breach of contract. Each theory has slightly different elements and remedies.
- Time limits: Claims are subject to statutes of limitation and possibly statutes of repose. Time limits vary based on the legal theory and facts - commonly claims are brought within a few years of discovery of the harm. Texas law recognizes discovery rules and doctrines such as equitable tolling and fraudulent concealment in appropriate circumstances. Because time limits can be critical, prompt action is essential.
- Proof of causation: For many malpractice claims that involve litigation malpractice, courts require proof that the underlying claim would have been successful but for the lawyer's negligence - sometimes called a "case-within-a-case" approach. This can require reconstructing the outcome that would have occurred with competent representation.
- Fee disputes and arbitration: Texas provides procedures for fee arbitration and other dispute-resolution mechanisms related to attorney fees. Fee disputes can often be resolved faster through arbitration than through a malpractice lawsuit.
- Professional discipline: The State Bar of Texas enforces the Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct. Filing a grievance with the appropriate disciplinary authorities may lead to sanctions against an attorney, but it does not guarantee monetary recovery for clients.
- Local courts and procedure: Malpractice lawsuits are typically filed in state district court in Hidalgo County or the county where the attorney practices or where the harm occurred. Federal courts may have jurisdiction in limited situations, such as diversity of citizenship or federal claims.
Legal malpractice generally means that an attorney failed to act with the level of skill, care, and diligence that a reasonably competent attorney would exercise in similar circumstances, and that failure caused the client to suffer a loss. Examples include missing statutes of limitation, filing errors, failing to investigate key facts, conflicts of interest, or misappropriating client funds.
If you had an attorney-client relationship and can identify a specific error or omission by your lawyer that you believe caused you monetary harm, you may have a claim. A malpractice attorney will evaluate whether you can establish breach, causation, and damages, and whether the claim is timely under applicable time limits.
A malpractice lawsuit seeks money damages for harm caused by an attorney's negligence or breach of contract. A disciplinary complaint asks the State Bar to investigate ethics violations and may result in sanctions such as suspension or disbarment. A disciplinary finding does not automatically create a right to financial recovery, and a malpractice suit can proceed regardless of disciplinary action.
Time limits vary by claim type and circumstances. Texas law applies statutes of limitation and may delay the start of the limitations period until you discovered or reasonably should have discovered the malpractice. Because deadlines can be strict and fact-specific, you should consult a malpractice lawyer promptly to preserve your rights.
In many malpractice cases, expert testimony is required to establish the standard of care and to show that the attorney departed from that standard. However, when the attorney's error is within common knowledge - for example, clear misappropriation of funds or missing a statute of limitations on its face - a court may allow a claim without an expert. Your attorney will advise whether an expert is likely necessary for your case.
Yes, but you must usually show that your lawyer's negligence caused the loss - for litigation malpractice, that often means proving that the underlying claim would have succeeded or that you would have obtained a better result with competent representation. This can make such cases complex because you must reconstruct the "what would have happened" scenario.
Recoverable damages typically include actual financial losses caused by the malpractice. Examples include lost settlement amounts, judgments or reduced awards, additional legal fees necessary to correct the error, and sometimes consequential damages. Punitive damages are rare and generally require proof of intentional or malicious misconduct.
Some attorneys carry professional liability insurance, which can be a source of recovery. If an attorney lacks insurance or has insufficient coverage, recovery may be limited to the attorney's personal assets or other available remedies. A malpractice lawyer can evaluate practical options, including settlement versus litigation.
Both actions can be appropriate, but their purposes differ. A grievance pursues professional discipline, while a lawsuit seeks compensation. Filing a grievance does not delay a malpractice claim unless a specific procedural rule applies. Consulting a malpractice attorney will help determine the optimal sequence and whether pursuing both avenues makes sense.
Fee arrangements vary. Many malpractice attorneys handle cases on a contingency-fee basis - they are paid a percentage of the recovery only if you win - or on a hybrid arrangement. Some require an initial consultation. Discuss fees, case expenses, and how costs will be advanced or deducted before you retain counsel.
When you are evaluating or pursuing a legal malpractice matter in McAllen, the following types of organizations and resources can be helpful:
- State Bar of Texas - for information about filing grievances, fee arbitration programs, and the Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct.
- Hidalgo County Bar Association or local bar groups - for referrals to experienced local attorneys and local practice information.
- County clerk and district court resources in Hidalgo County - for records, procedural rules, and filing information if litigation is necessary.
- Free or low-cost legal aid and legal clinics - for people who may not be able to afford private counsel, local legal aid programs may provide initial guidance or referrals.
- Malpractice defense and insurance information - for understanding how professional liability insurance and insurer processes can affect a claim.
If you believe you have a legal malpractice issue in McAllen, consider these practical next steps:
- Preserve documents and evidence. Collect all files, emails, pleadings, calendars, fee agreements, billing records, settlement offers, and any correspondence with the attorney. Do not destroy or alter files and avoid deleting relevant communications.
- Create a clear timeline. Write a chronological summary of events, decisions, and communications that you think show the attorney's error and the resulting harm.
- Get a consultation with an experienced legal malpractice attorney. An initial consultation will help you understand whether you have a viable claim, the likely defenses, potential damages, and applicable time limits.
- Consider parallel actions carefully. Your malpractice lawyer can explain whether you should also file a grievance with the State Bar, pursue fee arbitration, or proceed directly to a civil claim.
- Act promptly. Statutes of limitation and other procedural deadlines can bar claims if you wait too long. Even if you are unsure whether you have a claim, early consultation preserves your options.
Disclaimer - This guide provides general information about legal malpractice issues in McAllen and Texas and is not a substitute for legal advice. For advice about your specific situation, consult a licensed attorney who handles legal malpractice matters in Texas.
