Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
Medical malpractice - often called medical negligence - refers to situations where a health professional or healthcare provider fails to provide treatment to the standard reasonably expected, and that failure causes harm. In Gorey, as elsewhere in Ireland, these claims are governed by general principles of negligence under Irish civil law. A successful claim normally requires proof that the healthcare provider owed the patient a duty of care, breached that duty by falling below the accepted standard, and caused demonstrable damage or loss as a result.
Cases can arise after treatment in a public hospital, a private hospital, a GP surgery, dental practice, or other healthcare setting. If the respondent is a public body - for example, a public hospital within the Health Service Executive - the claim will often be handled through the State Claims Agency. Private clinicians and institutions are usually covered by professional indemnity insurance.
Medical malpractice matters are legally and medically complex. You may need a lawyer if any of the following apply:
- You believe a misdiagnosis, delayed diagnosis, surgical error, medication error, obstetric or maternity care failure, or other clinical mistake led to injury or worsened an existing condition.
- You need help obtaining and reviewing your medical records and notes - a solicitor can request records formally and identify gaps or inconsistencies.
- Causation is unclear - you need medical experts to establish that the healthcare provider caused the harm and not the underlying condition.
- You need to calculate present and future losses - legal advice helps quantify past medical costs, future care needs, loss of earnings, and general damages for pain and suffering.
- You are considering making a formal complaint or starting court proceedings and want to know the likely cost, timeframes, and chances of success.
- You need assistance with alternative dispute resolution, such as negotiation or mediation, or with settlement proposals.
Key legal points to understand about medical malpractice in Gorey and the Republic of Ireland:
- Elements of a claim - a claimant must establish duty of care, breach of that duty, causation, and that damages resulted. The standard of care is judged against what a reasonable body of medical opinion would consider acceptable, and courts will assess whether that opinion is logically defensible.
- Burden of proof - medical negligence claims are decided on the balance of probabilities - in other words, it must be more likely than not that the negligence caused the harm.
- Time limits - there is generally a two-year limitation period. The two-year period normally runs from the date of knowledge - when the claimant knew, or should reasonably have known, they had suffered injury because of the healthcare provided. Special rules apply for minors and people lacking capacity - in those situations the limitation period may be extended or run from a different date.
- Public versus private providers - claims involving public hospitals and staff are often managed through the State Claims Agency. Claims against private practitioners are usually pursued directly against the practitioner and their insurer.
- Court process and remedies - claims are brought in the civil courts. Depending on value and complexity, cases may go to the Circuit Court or the High Court. Remedies typically involve monetary compensation for pain and suffering, past and future medical costs, lost earnings, and costs of care.
- Expert evidence - medical expert reports are fundamental. A claim will usually require at least one independent expert to support assertions about the standard of care and causation.
Generally you have a two-year limitation period. The clock usually starts from the date you knew, or ought reasonably to have known, that the injury was caused by healthcare. There are special rules for children and people who lack mental capacity, so seek advice promptly if you are unsure.
Common situations include misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis, surgical errors, medication mistakes, failure to obtain informed consent, poor maternity or obstetric care, and inadequate follow-up. Not every bad outcome is negligence - the treatment must have fallen below the accepted standard.
Yes. Expert medical evidence is normally essential to establish that the standard of care was breached and that the breach caused your injury. Your solicitor will arrange for an independent expert to review the records and prepare a report for use in settlement negotiations or court.
You are entitled to request copies of your medical records from any provider that treated you. Your solicitor can issue a formal request and, if necessary, obtain records through court disclosure once proceedings begin.
Claims arising from care in public hospitals are frequently handled through the State Claims Agency on behalf of the Health Service Executive. Your solicitor will advise the proper defendant and the correct procedure.
Yes. You can make a formal complaint to the healthcare provider, to the Health Service Executive if it is a public service matter, or to professional regulators such as the Medical Council or the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Ireland. Complaints can lead to investigations, apologies, or changes in practice even if you do not bring civil proceedings.
Costs vary depending on complexity. Many solicitors offer an initial consultation and may work on conditional fee agreements - commonly called no win-no fee arrangements - or other fee models. Even with a conditional fee agreement, discuss how disbursements and court costs will be handled. Recovering legal costs from the losing party is possible, but not guaranteed to cover all your fees.
Timelines vary widely. Some cases settle after months of negotiation; complex cases with full expert evidence and court hearings can take several years. Early legal advice can help manage expectations and preserve evidence.
Compensation can include general damages for pain and suffering, special damages for past and future medical and care costs, loss of earnings, loss of pension or capacity to work, and expenses incurred as a result of the injury. The exact award depends on the facts of the case and medical evidence.
Steps to take right away include keeping a record of events and symptoms, preserving any documents or correspondence, requesting your medical records, getting a second medical opinion if appropriate, and contacting a solicitor experienced in medical negligence. Avoid signing documents that waive your rights without legal advice.
Useful bodies and organisations that can provide information, complaints handling, or regulatory oversight in Ireland include:
- Medical Council - regulator for doctors in Ireland.
- Nursing and Midwifery Board of Ireland - regulator for nurses and midwives.
- State Claims Agency - handles clinical negligence claims for public health bodies.
- Health Service Executive - local public health provider and complaints point for public hospitals and services.
- Office of the Ombudsman - for complaints about public services where internal remedies are exhausted.
- Citizens Information - provides general guidance about rights and the legal system.
- Law Society of Ireland - for finding solicitors and information about legal services.
- Patient advocacy groups and local support organisations - for practical and emotional support after medical harm.
If you think you have suffered medical negligence, act promptly:
- Document the facts - write down dates, events, names of staff, and the effect on your life.
- Obtain your medical records - ask the treating facility or solicitor to request them formally.
- Seek medical advice - obtain an independent clinical opinion about the care you received and the harm you suffered.
- Contact a solicitor experienced in medical negligence - arrange an initial consultation to discuss the merits of your case, likely costs, time limits, and next steps.
- Consider making a formal complaint - to the healthcare provider, to HSE for public services, or to the relevant regulator if appropriate.
- Preserve evidence - keep bills, receipts, photographs, and any correspondence relating to your care and losses.
A solicitor can explain the legal test, handle expert reports, manage communications with insurers or the State Claims Agency, and represent you in negotiations or court. Early legal advice helps protect your rights and ensures you meet procedural requirements and deadlines.
