Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
An appeal is the legal process by which a higher court reviews a decision made by a lower court or administrative body. In Buffalo appeals most commonly arise from state court cases in Erie County and from federal cases filed in the Western District of New York. The state appellate path typically moves from the trial court to the Appellate Division - Fourth Department, and then, in limited situations, to the New York Court of Appeals. Federal cases from Buffalo proceed from the United States District Court for the Western District of New York to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, and potentially to the United States Supreme Court. Appeals focus on alleged legal or procedural errors made at trial rather than re-trying factual disputes. The appellate process involves strict procedures, short deadlines, written briefs, and sometimes oral argument.
Appellate practice is a specialized area of law. You may need a lawyer if you are considering an appeal for any of these common reasons:
- To review whether legal errors at trial affected the outcome, such as incorrect jury instructions, improper admission or exclusion of evidence, or erroneous interpretations of the law.
- To challenge the sufficiency of the evidence supporting a verdict or conviction.
- To seek relief from procedural mistakes, like improper sentencing in a criminal case or jurisdictional errors in civil matters.
- To pursue post-judgment relief after losing at trial or in administrative proceedings, including motions for a new trial or to set aside a judgment.
- To handle complex procedural requirements - preserving issues for appeal, preparing a complete record, obtaining transcripts, drafting persuasive briefs, and meeting exact filing and formatting rules.
Experienced appellate attorneys know how to frame legal issues to improve chances of success and how to navigate local court practices in Buffalo and Erie County.
Key local and regional features that shape appeals in Buffalo include the following:
- Court structure - State appeals in Buffalo and Erie County generally go to the Appellate Division - Fourth Department, which reviews decisions from trial-level courts including the Supreme Court, County Court, Family Court, Surrogate's Court, and local city or municipal courts. The New York Court of Appeals is the state's highest court but hears fewer cases and often requires permission to appeal in non-final or discretionary situations.
- Federal path - Federal cases filed in the Western District of New York in Buffalo appeal to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals. Federal appellate practice follows federal rules of procedure and distinct timelines.
- Preservation rules - To raise an issue on appeal in New York, you usually must have objected at trial or otherwise preserved the issue in the record. Failure to preserve an issue will generally prevent appellate review unless a narrow exception applies.
- Deadlines and filing - Appellate deadlines are strict. Civil and criminal appeals typically have short windows to file a notice of appeal and to perfect the appeal. Courts in the region also have local rules about filing format, length limits for briefs, appendix requirements, and electronic filing procedures.
- Standards of review - Appellate courts apply different standards of review depending on the issue. Questions of law are usually reviewed de novo - meaning the appellate court reviews them from scratch. Factual findings are given deference and reviewed for clear error. Discretionary trial rulings are reviewed for abuse of discretion. Knowing the applicable standard is crucial to crafting effective appellate arguments.
- Relief and remedies - Appellate courts can affirm, reverse, modify, or remand cases back to the trial court for further proceedings. They may also vacate judgments or order new trials in appropriate situations. Remedies available may vary by the type of case and whether the appeal is in state or federal court.
An appeal is a request to a higher court to review a lower court or administrative decision for legal or procedural errors. Appeals typically do not re-weigh witness credibility or hear new evidence. Instead, they examine the trial record and legal arguments to decide if the lower court made a reversible error.
Timelines vary by the type of case and the court system - state or federal. Many appeals have short deadlines, often measured in days or weeks from the entry of judgment or from receipt of written notice of entry. Because deadlines are strict and can differ by court and case type, contact a lawyer or the clerk of the relevant court immediately to confirm the timeline for your situation.
Yes. In most circumstances you must have raised an objection or otherwise preserved the issue during the trial to get appellate review. If you fail to object or create a record, appellate courts are likely to decline review except in exceptional circumstances, such as plain error that affects substantial rights.
Generally no. Appeals usually focus on the existing trial record. New evidence is not allowed on appeal except in limited situations, such as when evidence could not have been discovered with reasonable diligence before trial or when a separate post-conviction or collateral attack process is available. If you believe new evidence is dispositive, an attorney can advise whether a motion for a new trial or a post-conviction remedy is appropriate.
Common grounds include legal errors such as incorrect jury instructions, erroneous rulings on evidence, violations of constitutional rights in criminal cases, insufficient evidence to support a verdict, or mistakes in sentencing. Procedural irregularities that affect a party's substantial rights can also support reversal. Success depends on proving the error was prejudicial - meaning it likely affected the outcome.
Appeal timelines vary widely. Simple appeals may be resolved in months, while complex matters can take a year or more. If the case progresses to the state or federal supreme court level, additional time is common. Delays can occur due to briefing schedules, requests for transcripts, motions, and calendar availability for oral argument.
Yes, you have the right to represent yourself, but appellate practice involves procedural technicalities and persuasive legal writing. Self-representation can be risky because missed deadlines or formatting errors can result in dismissal. If cost is an issue, consider limited-scope representation, legal aid, or consult local bar association resources for referrals.
The appellate brief is your primary tool for persuading the appellate court. It sets forth the questions presented, the relevant facts from the record, legal argument supported by authorities, and the relief requested. Most courts also require a short appendix or record extract containing the key documents and portions of the transcript that the court will review. Briefs must follow strict formatting and length rules.
Not all appeals have oral argument. If allowed or requested, oral argument gives counsel an opportunity to highlight the strongest points from the brief and answer judges' questions. It is generally a short session focused on legal issues rather than re-arguing factual disputes. Appellate attorneys prepare to answer precise questions from the panel of judges.
Sometimes. Courts may issue a stay of enforcement while an appeal is pending, but stays are discretionary and may require posting a bond or meeting other conditions. In criminal cases, defendants may seek release pending appeal in certain circumstances. Consult an attorney promptly if you need a stay to prevent enforcement.
Here are local and regional resources that can be helpful when seeking appellate guidance in Buffalo:
- Appellate Division - Fourth Department - the intermediate appellate court that handles many state appeals from the Buffalo area.
- New York Court of Appeals - the state's highest court for significant legal questions, often requiring permission to appeal.
- United States District Court for the Western District of New York - the federal trial court in Buffalo for federal matters.
- United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit - the federal appellate court that decides appeals from Western New York federal courts.
- Erie County Supreme Court, County Court, Family Court, Surrogate's Court and local city and municipal courts - trial courts that generate appeals in the region.
- Erie County Bar Association and local bar committees - offer lawyer referrals and may provide resources on appellate practitioners.
- Legal Aid organizations and public defender offices - for individuals who may qualify for free or low-cost representation.
- Local law libraries and university law libraries - for case law research, court rules, and procedural guides.
- Clerk offices at the relevant courts - to confirm filing deadlines, fees, transcript ordering procedures, and local rules.
If you think you need to appeal a decision in Buffalo, follow these practical steps:
- Act quickly - determine the applicable deadline and calendar your actions immediately. Missing a deadline often means losing the right to appeal.
- Preserve the record - if you are still at trial or sentencing, make clear objections on the record and request that important rulings be made part of the record.
- Obtain the trial transcript - appeals normally require the trial transcript. Order it promptly because preparation can take time and incurs costs.
- Consult an appellate lawyer - seek a lawyer with appellate experience who can evaluate your issues, advise on likely success, and manage technical filing and briefing requirements.
- Discuss costs and funding - ask about fees, filing costs, transcript charges, and potential fee-shifting or indigency options if cost is a concern.
- Decide on strategy - your attorney will help you select which issues to raise, whether to seek a stay, and whether settlement or alternative remedies might be appropriate while the appeal proceeds.
- Prepare and file required documents - file any notice of appeal or necessary motions, assemble the appendix or record extracts, and draft persuasive briefs within required formats.
- Prepare for the possibility of further review - if you lose at the intermediate appellate level, discuss with counsel whether further review at the New York Court of Appeals or the federal appellate level is realistic and advisable.
Appellate work is detail-oriented and governed by strict procedural rules. Early consultation with an experienced appellate attorney can preserve your rights and improve your chances of a favorable outcome.
