Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
An appeal is a legal process where a higher court reviews a decision made by a lower court or tribunal. In Denver, appeals generally follow the Colorado appellate structure for state-law matters and the federal appellate structure for federal-law matters. Common state-level steps include filing a notice of appeal, preparing the record on appeal, submitting written briefs, and (in some cases) presenting oral argument. The Colorado Court of Appeals and the Colorado Supreme Court are the primary state appellate bodies. For federal cases arising in Denver, the United States District Court for the District of Colorado handles trial matters and appeals proceed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.
Appeals focus on whether legal errors occurred that affected the outcome of the case. Appellate courts do not rehear witness testimony or accept new evidence in most cases. Instead, they review the written record from the trial court and decide whether legal standards were applied correctly. Possible results include affirming the lower court, reversing the decision, remanding the case for further proceedings, or modifying the judgment.
Appellate practice is highly specialized. The process is governed by precise rules, strict deadlines, and specific briefing and record requirements. You may need a lawyer because:
- Complex procedural rules dictate how and when an appeal must be filed and pursued. Missing a deadline or failing to preserve an issue can forfeit appellate rights.
- Raising the right legal issues and articulating persuasive standards of review requires appellate experience. Appellate lawyers craft legal arguments focused on legal error rather than re-arguing factual disputes.
- Preparing the record on appeal - ordering transcripts, designating exhibits, and assembling the record - is technical and time-sensitive.
- Brief-writing is different from trial advocacy. Appellate briefs must be concise, legally focused, and cite binding precedent and authorities effectively.
- In criminal matters, appeals involve additional considerations such as plea-waiver issues, collateral review, sentencing challenges, and potential consequences for custody or parole.
- If you are indigent, an experienced attorney can help obtain appointed counsel or guide you through fee-waiver and public defender processes.
Key aspects of local appellate practice in Denver and Colorado include:
- Colorado Appellate Framework - Colorado has appellate rules that govern civil and criminal appeals, the content and timing of filings, and procedural steps. These rules determine how appeals move from trial courts to the Colorado Court of Appeals and, in some cases, to the Colorado Supreme Court.
- Court Hierarchy - For state cases, trial court decisions typically go to the Colorado Court of Appeals, with further review by the Colorado Supreme Court by petition. For federal cases originating in Denver, appeals go to the Tenth Circuit. Administrative agencies may have separate review paths that lead to district courts or appellate courts depending on the statute involved.
- Preservation of Issues - Parties must generally object at trial or take certain procedural steps to preserve issues for appeal. Issues not properly preserved are often barred from appellate review.
- Standards of Review - Appellate courts apply different standards depending on the issue. Common standards include de novo review for legal questions, abuse-of-discretion review for many trial-court decisions, and clearly erroneous review for certain factual findings. The applicable standard greatly affects the likelihood of reversal.
- The Record on Appeal - The appellate record consists of the trial docket, transcripts, exhibits, and lower-court filings. Appellate courts decide based on that record, so completeness and accuracy are critical.
- Remedies and Outcomes - Appellate courts may affirm, reverse, vacate, modify, or remand for further proceedings. In some cases, courts can order new trials or alter judgments. Costs, bonds, and stays pending appeal may be governed by local rules and statutes.
- Timing and Deadlines - Appellate deadlines tend to be short and strictly enforced. Timely filing of notices, briefs, and requests for extensions is essential. Local rules also control when and how to seek interlocutory relief or emergency stays.
- County and District Differences - Some appeals, such as from county courts or municipal courts, follow specialized local paths. For example, certain county-court matters are appealed to district courts for trial de novo instead of straight appellate review. Knowing the correct destination and procedure for your appeal is critical.
You can appeal final orders and, in some circumstances, certain interlocutory orders. Final judgments that resolve the main dispute are commonly appealable. Some interlocutory orders may be reviewable by permission or via special writs. Administrative decisions may have their own appeal pathways. The right to appeal depends on the case type and the governing statutes and rules.
Start by filing a notice of appeal or equivalent document with the court that issued the judgment. You must also follow local appellate rules about service, filing the record, and paying filing fees or seeking a fee waiver. Because requirements and timelines are strict, consult an attorney promptly to ensure proper initiation.
Timelines vary. A completed appeal to the intermediate appellate court can take many months to over a year, depending on complexity, the need for transcripts, and court backlog. Petitions for further review by a supreme court or federal appeals can add more months. Emergency motions and stays are handled more quickly.
Costs include filing fees, transcript costs, copying and record assembly fees, and attorney fees. Appellate litigation can be costly because of specialized brief-writing and review. Indigent parties may qualify for appointed counsel in criminal cases or fee waivers in civil matters depending on eligibility.
Appellate courts do not normally grant new trials simply because they disagree with factual findings. They may remand for a new trial if a substantial legal error affected the trial outcome or if the record shows a deprivation of a fair trial. In some cases, county-court appeals may lead to a trial de novo at the district level.
Yes. Many appellate issues must be preserved by timely objection or a motion in the trial court. Failure to preserve an issue can bar appellate review unless an exception applies, such as plain error review, which is a narrow and rarely successful path.
The standard of review determines how deferential the appellate court will be to the trial court. De novo review involves no deference and allows the appellate court to substitute its own judgment on legal questions. Abuse-of-discretion review is deferential and harder to overcome. Understanding the applicable standard is crucial to framing arguments effectively.
Appealing after a guilty plea is limited because defendants typically waive certain rights by pleading. Some appeals are still possible - for example, challenges to jurisdiction, constitutional issues not waived by the plea, or ineffective assistance of counsel claims raised in post-conviction proceedings. Consult counsel promptly to evaluate options.
Missing a filing deadline is serious and may forfeit appellate rights. In rare circumstances, courts may allow relief for excusable neglect or statutory exceptions, but such relief is hard to obtain. If you believe a deadline was missed for a valid reason, consult an attorney immediately to explore whether any remedial options exist.
Generally, appellate courts do not consider new evidence. They review the record created in the trial court. If new evidence is discovered after trial, a party may seek post-judgment relief in the trial court under the appropriate rules rather than on direct appeal.
Helpful local and state resources for appeals include state and local courts and professional organizations that provide guides, forms, and contact information. Typical resources to consult are:
- The Colorado Judicial Branch, which publishes rules and court information for state appeals.
- The Colorado Court of Appeals and the Colorado Supreme Court for appellate procedures and published opinions.
- The United States District Court for the District of Colorado and the Tenth Circuit for federal appeals arising in Denver.
- Local trial courts in Denver such as the Denver County Court and the Denver District Court for order entries and records.
- The Colorado Bar Association and the local Denver bar associations for lawyer referrals and practice resources.
- Legal aid organizations and public defender offices for qualifying low-income litigants seeking representation.
- Law libraries and court self-help centers for forms, procedural guides, and research assistance.
If you think you need to appeal a decision in Denver, follow these steps:
- Act quickly. Determine the date your judgment or order was entered and check applicable appellate deadlines. Time is critical.
- Preserve your record. Identify transcripts and exhibits you will need and request them promptly from the trial court.
- Consult an appellate lawyer. Seek an attorney with experience in appellate briefs and oral argument. Many appellate lawyers offer initial consultations to assess the viability of an appeal.
- Consider costs and funding. Understand filing fees, transcript expenses, and attorney fees. Ask about payment plans, fee waivers, or appointed counsel if you qualify.
- Evaluate alternative remedies. Depending on your case, there may be post-judgment motions, settlement opportunities, or administrative remedies that are faster or more appropriate than a full appeal.
- Prepare your brief. Work with counsel to develop a focused legal argument grounded in the record and relevant standards of review.
- Monitor deadlines and procedural requirements. Ensure all filings comply with local appellate rules regarding format, service, and timing.
Appeals are powerful but procedural tools that require careful planning and precise execution. Getting experienced guidance early improves your chances of presenting the strongest possible case to an appellate court.
