Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
Appeals are the formal process by which a higher court or tribunal reviews a decision made by a lower court or tribunal. In Fairfield, a suburb of western Sydney in New South Wales, appeals follow the broader New South Wales court and tribunal system. Depending on the type of matter - criminal, civil, family, or administrative - an appeal may be made from a Local Court, the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal, the District Court, or the Supreme Court to the next appropriate appellate body. The aim of an appeal is not usually to rehear all evidence, but to determine whether legal errors, procedural unfairness, or significant factual mistakes affected the original outcome.
For people in Fairfield, the relevant institutions include the Fairfield Local Court, district and supreme courts sitting in the Sydney region, and state tribunals. The pathway and rules for appeals vary by court and by the type of case, so local court registry staff, legal advisers, or court rules should be consulted early.
Appeals can be legally complex, highly technical and time sensitive. You may need a lawyer if you are considering an appeal for any of the following common reasons:
- You have been convicted of an offence or received a sentence you believe is unfair, excessive or contrary to law.
- You disagree with a civil judgment about money, property, contract or personal injury and believe the judge made a legal error or wrongly applied the law.
- A tribunal decision affecting your employment, tenancy, licensing, immigration, or administrative rights appears to have involved procedural unfairness or misunderstanding of the relevant statute.
- You are served with an appeal by the other side and need to respond within strict time limits.
- You need help identifying viable grounds of appeal, preparing the appeal book and transcript requests, drafting written submissions, or presenting oral argument in an appellate court.
An experienced appeal lawyer will assess whether your matter has arguable grounds, explain costs and prospects, manage strict filing requirements and deadlines, and present legal arguments in writing and orally. In criminal matters, specialist appellate criminal lawyers often have particular expertise in sentencing principles, miscarriages of justice and appellate advocacy.
Appeals in Fairfield are governed by New South Wales law and court rules. Key points to be aware of include:
- Court hierarchy - The typical path is Local Court to District Court, District Court to Supreme Court, and Supreme Court to the Court of Appeal or Court of Criminal Appeal within the Supreme Court of NSW. The High Court of Australia is the final appellate court for matters that meet its special criteria.
- Time limits - Time limits to lodge an appeal or seek leave to appeal are strict. Many appeals require lodgement within a few weeks of the decision - commonly 14 to 28 days - but this period varies with the court and the type of decision. Missing a deadline can permanently bar an appeal unless exceptional circumstances are shown.
- Grounds for appeal - Appeals are generally based on errors of law, procedural unfairness, or, less commonly, findings of fact that are plainly wrong. Some appeals allow challenges to sentencing decisions on the basis they were manifestly excessive or proceeded on incorrect principles.
- Evidence and new material - Appellate courts usually review the existing record. New evidence is permitted only in narrow circumstances, such as where it was not reasonably available at the original hearing and could materially affect the outcome.
- Practice rules - Civil appeals will often follow the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and specific practice directions of the Court of Appeal. Criminal appeals follow their own procedures and criminal appeal legislation. NCAT and other tribunals have separate appeal and internal review pathways.
- Costs - Losing an appeal can expose you to an adverse costs order. In criminal matters, there are different rules about costs compared with civil appeals. It is important to obtain legal advice about the likely costs exposure before proceeding.
An appeal is a review by a higher court of the legal correctness or fairness of a decision made by a lower court. A retrial re-hears the case from the start and may be ordered in limited situations, for example when an appeal court finds the original trial was unfair to the extent that the only remedy is a new hearing.
Time limits vary by court and type of matter. Commonly the limit is between 14 and 28 days from the date of the decision or sentence, but some appeals may have shorter or longer windows. You should check the specific rules for the court or tribunal involved and seek legal advice quickly because extensions are rarely granted.
Typical grounds include errors of law, procedural unfairness, incorrect application of legal principles, or findings of fact that were plainly wrong. In sentencing appeals, you can argue that the sentence was manifestly excessive or that the sentencing judge applied wrong principles. Your lawyer will help identify and frame viable grounds.
Generally not. Appellate courts review the record from the original hearing. New evidence is only allowed in exceptional circumstances, such as when it could not have been obtained with reasonable diligence earlier and it would likely have affected the outcome.
Some appeals require leave or permission from the court before they can proceed, especially appeals to higher courts or cases involving interlocutory decisions. Your solicitor can determine whether leave is required and can prepare the application if necessary.
Appellate hearings usually focus on legal argument, not the re-examination of witnesses. Parties typically submit an appeal book, written submissions and appear before a panel of judges who ask questions. In criminal appeals, the focus may be on conviction safety or sentencing principles.
Costs vary widely depending on complexity, the level of court, the need for transcript and appeal book preparation, and whether the matter proceeds to an oral hearing. Appeals can be expensive, and there may be a risk of paying the other side's costs if you lose. Ask for a clear estimate and costs agreement with your lawyer.
Yes, many tribunal decisions have an internal appeal or review mechanism, or can be appealed to a court on questions of law. The pathway depends on the tribunal and the legislation governing it. Time limits and grounds differ from court appeals, so seek advice specific to the tribunal involved.
Transcripts of the original hearing and a properly prepared appeal book are essential. They form the record the appellate court reviews. The appeal book compiles the relevant documents, judgments and evidence that support your grounds of appeal. Preparing it correctly is a technical requirement and often handled by your lawyer or a paralegal.
Success depends on the strength of the grounds, the quality of the legal argument, the nature of the original error and the standard of review. Appellate courts do not overturn decisions lightly. An experienced appellate lawyer can provide an honest assessment of prospects after reviewing the file and identifying arguable errors.
For people in Fairfield seeking help with appeals, consider the following resources and organisations for information and assistance:
- Fairfield Local Court registry and court staff for basic procedural information.
- District and Supreme Court registries for appeal lodgement procedures in the Sydney region.
- NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) for tribunal appeal pathways and internal reviews.
- LawAccess NSW for general legal information and referrals.
- Legal Aid NSW for information on eligibility for legal assistance in criminal and some civil matters.
- Fairfield Legal Centre and other community legal centres for low-cost or no-cost legal help and initial advice.
- Law Society of New South Wales and the NSW Bar Association to find solicitors and barristers experienced in appeals.
- Court reporting and transcript services to obtain official records of hearings.
- Victims Services and other specialist support agencies for people affected by criminal matters who need assistance navigating the appeal process.
If you are considering an appeal in Fairfield, follow these practical steps:
- Act quickly - check the decision date and find out the specific time limit for lodging an appeal or seeking leave. Missing a deadline can be fatal to your case.
- Obtain the judgment and file notes - secure copies of the written judgment, orders and any transcript of the hearing as soon as possible.
- Get legal advice - speak with an experienced appeal lawyer or a community legal centre to assess grounds, prospects and costs. Ask for a clear costs estimate and whether Legal Aid or pro bono assistance is available.
- Prepare the record - your lawyer will request transcripts, prepare the appeal book and file the necessary notice of appeal and supporting material with the correct registry.
- Consider alternatives - in some cases negotiation, settlement or seeking a rehearing at the original court may be more appropriate than an appeal.
- Attend to funding and representation - decide whether to instruct an appellate solicitor and barrister, and arrange funding. Understand potential cost risks if the appeal fails.
- Follow court directions - comply with all procedural steps, practice directions and filing requirements to preserve the appeal.
If you are unsure where to start, contact a local community legal centre or arrange an initial consultation with a solicitor experienced in appeals. Acting early and getting the right advice greatly improves your chances of navigating the appeal process effectively.
