Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
An appeal is the legal process used to challenge a trial court decision or certain administrative rulings. In Irvine, which is part of Orange County, appeals from local state trial courts generally proceed through the California appellate system, while federal matters move through the federal district and circuit courts. Appellate courts review the record from the trial level to determine whether legal errors occurred that affected the outcome. Appeals are not new trials - appellate judges typically review written briefs, the trial record, and sometimes hold oral argument to determine whether reversal, modification, remand, or affirmation of the lower court decision is appropriate.
If you believe the trial court made a legal error that affected your case outcome, an appellate lawyer can evaluate whether an appeal is viable and how strong the arguments are. Appellate practice is specialized - lawyers prepare briefs, craft legal standards of review arguments, and present oral argument if needed.
You may need a lawyer when deadlines and procedural rules are strict and technical. Missing a filing deadline or failing to preserve issues in the trial court can foreclose appellate review. An attorney helps preserve the record, order transcripts, and identify record references precisely.
Circumstances that commonly require appellate assistance include criminal convictions seeking reversal or resentencing, civil judgments with significant monetary exposure, family law orders affecting custody or support, administrative agency decisions, and appeals of injunctions or complex discovery rulings. Lawyers also advise on tactical options like post-trial motions, settlement offers, and whether to seek a stay of enforcement pending appeal.
Key elements of local appellate practice in Irvine and Orange County include the following. Trial-level cases are heard in the Orange County Superior Court. Appeals of state trial court decisions generally go to the California Courts of Appeal and ultimately to the California Supreme Court in limited circumstances. For federal matters, trial cases filed in the Central District of California typically appeal to the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
Procedural rules that matter locally include the California Rules of Court and the United States Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure. These rules govern notice of appeal, the content and formatting of briefs, page limits, service requirements, and the procedures for requesting transcripts and preparing the record on appeal.
Substantive and practical considerations you will encounter are standards of review - appellate courts apply different standards depending on the issue. Legal questions are often reviewed de novo, factual findings are reviewed for substantial evidence, and discretionary rulings are reviewed for abuse of discretion. Appellate courts generally do not take new evidence or reweigh witness credibility.
Deadlines, preservation of issues, and cost considerations are critical in local practice. To preserve issues for appeal, parties often must raise them at trial through timely objections or appropriate motions. Remedies on appeal can range from full reversal to remand for a new trial, modification of orders, or an affirmance. Some post-judgment enforcement actions may require a bond or stay to pause collection or execution while the appeal proceeds.
An appeal is a review by a higher court of the trial court record to determine whether legal errors occurred. A motion for a new trial is made to the trial court that heard the case and asks that court to reconsider or re-open the case because of errors, newly discovered evidence, or other grounds. Sometimes parties file post-judgment motions first and then appeal if those motions are denied.
Starting an appeal usually requires filing a notice of appeal or a notice of intent to appeal with the trial court clerk and serving the other parties. You must also secure the trial record and, if necessary, order reporter transcripts. Exact steps and timing depend on whether your case is in state or federal court and on the type of case. Because deadlines are strict, consult an attorney quickly.
Deadlines vary by case type and court. Time limits can be short and are strictly enforced. For many matters the window is measured in weeks rather than months, and for some post-trial remedies even shorter. Do not rely on general memory - verify the applicable deadline for your case and act promptly to protect your right to appeal.
Generally no. Appeals rely on the record created at the trial level. Appellate courts review what is already in the record; they do not receive new testimony or evidence except in very limited circumstances, such as when the new evidence meets narrow statutory or equitable standards and is properly presented through trial court procedures first.
No. Appellate courts do not re-try cases or make credibility determinations. They review the trial court record to decide whether legal errors or procedural mistakes occurred that affected the outcome. If errors are found, an appellate court may reverse or remand the matter for a new trial or further proceedings in the trial court.
Outcomes include affirmance of the trial court decision, reversal in whole or in part, remand for further proceedings, modification of the judgment or order, or dismissal of the appeal for procedural reasons. An appellate court may also issue limited relief, such as remanding for recalculation of damages or resentencing in criminal cases.
Appeals can take many months to more than a year depending on the court, complexity of the issues, need for transcripts, briefing schedules, and whether the court grants expedited or shortened timelines. Complex appeals that go to en banc review or to higher courts can take longer. Discuss timing expectations with counsel early.
Some trial lawyers also practice appeals, but appellate work involves specific skills - legal research, brief writing, and appellate advocacy - and an appellate specialist can offer advantages. Consider using counsel with appellate experience, particularly for complex legal issues or high-stakes matters.
Yes. Parties can negotiate a settlement at any stage, including during an appeal. Settlement can be practical to avoid additional costs and uncertainty. If a judgment is being enforced, you may need a stay or bond while negotiations occur. An attorney can negotiate settlement terms and coordinate dismissal of the appeal if a settlement is reached.
Missing the deadline typically means losing the right to appeal. Courts are strict about timing and will dismiss late filings. In rare cases, equitable relief such as a petition for writ might be available, but those remedies are limited and difficult to obtain. If you think you missed a deadline, consult an appellate attorney immediately to explore any potential remedies.
California Courts - Self-Help and Appellate Procedure resources can provide general guidance about appellate steps and forms. The Orange County Superior Court clerk's office can explain filing procedures at the trial level. For state appeals involving Orange County, the California Court of Appeal for the appropriate district and division handles appellate filings. For federal appeals arising from the Central District of California, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals handles appeals.
The State Bar of California offers lawyer referral services and information about attorney qualifications. The Orange County Bar Association and local appellate practice sections can help identify attorneys with appellate experience. Legal aid organizations in Orange County, such as the Legal Aid Society of Orange County and the Public Law Center, may provide assistance for qualifying low-income individuals. Local law libraries and university law clinics can also be useful resources for legal research and guidance.
Gather your trial documents - judgment or order, trial transcript indexes, exhibits, motions, and related filings. Note the date of the judgment or order and any post-judgment rulings to determine deadlines. Request and preserve transcripts promptly if you will need the reporter record for appeal.
Schedule a consultation with an appellate lawyer as soon as possible. During the consultation, ask about the merits of appeal, applicable deadlines, likely costs, fee structure, and potential outcomes. If you cannot afford counsel, contact local legal aid organizations or the State Bar for referral options.
Consider immediate procedural steps your counsel may recommend - filing a timely notice of appeal, making post-trial motions to preserve issues, seeking a stay of enforcement, or negotiating settlement. Keep a written record of all deadlines, filings, and correspondence with the court and opposing counsel.
Proceeding promptly and working with counsel experienced in appellate practice will help protect your rights and improve the chances of a favorable outcome on appeal.
