Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
Free Consultation: 15 mins
Appeal law in Toronto, Canada, is a specific area of the Canadian legal system that allows individuals or businesses to request a higher court review of decisions made by a lower court. An appeal seeks to overturn the judgment if the appellant believes it was unfair or legally flawed. In Toronto's jurisdiction, cases can be appealed at various levels, from the Small Claims Court to the Supreme Court of Canada, depending on the nature of the original case.
While not mandatory, hiring a lawyer to handle an appeal can be beneficial because of the legal complexities involved. Common situations where you might require a lawyer include when you believe your case was not handled fairly due to errors in law or process, or when new and significant evidence has surfaced. Lawyers specializing in appeals have specific knowledge and expertise that can help navigate the rigours of the appeal process, articulate the grounds of appeal, and provide a strategic approach to push your case towards a favourable outcome.
Toronto’s appeal laws, consistent with provincial and Canadian federal laws, allow for an appeal if there are grounds based on errors in law, fact, or mixed fact and law. Typically, you have 30 days to file an appeal after a judgment. This does not apply to criminal cases, where a defendant has an automatic right to appeal. The Ontario Court of Appeal, which services Toronto, is one of the most influential courts in the process, where many cases can be further appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada.
An appeal is a legal process where a party requests a higher court to review the decision of a lower court because they believe there were significant errors that affected the outcome.
Any party unsatisfied with the decision of a lower court, typically known as the appellant, can file an appeal; however, they must have legitimate reasons for doing so.
Generally, you have 30 days from the date of the lower court's decision to file an appeal in Toronto. Some cases may have different timelines, so consulting a lawyer is often beneficial.
While you can choose to represent yourself, it's generally not recommended due to legal complexities associated with the appeal process. Having a lawyer can improve the chances of a successful appeal.
An appeal begins with filing a Notice of Appeal to the higher court. This is followed by the preparation and submission of an appeal record, factum, and book of authorities. Hearings will then be scheduled, where appellate judges will review the documents, listen to arguments, and make a decision.
Not all decisions can be appealed. Certain lower court decisions may be final, particularly where the law gives the judge a great deal of discretion. Your lawyer can advise you on whether your case is appealable.
New evidence is typically not permitted at the appeal stage. Appeals are generally based on the 'record' from the initial trial which includes, testimony, exhibits and other evidence presented at the initial trial. Exceptions may apply under certain conditions.
An appeal usually doesn't halt the enforcement of the decision from the lower court, unless a stay of proceedings is granted.
An appeal hearing is largely focused on legal arguments related to the lower court's decision errors rather than a retrial of the original case. Your lawyer, and the respondent's lawyer will present their arguments, and the panel of judges will make their decision accordingly.
If you win the appeal, the appellate court may overturn the original decision, order a new trial, amend the judgment, or vary the sentence. The specific outcome depends on the nature of your case and the error that led to the appeal.
For more information on the appeal process in Toronto, you can access the Ontario Court of Appeal Practice Directions and Policies. Additionally, the Law Society of Ontario can provide more legal resources or lawyer referrals. For free or low-cost legal support, you can also consider visiting the Legal Aid Ontario website.
If you need legal assistance in an appeal, the first step is to consult with a lawyer experienced in appeal law. You can contact the Law Society of Ontario for referrals or check online legal platforms. It’s important to reach out as soon as possible due to the limited timeframe for filing an appeal. Once you engage a lawyer, they will guide you through the appeal process, from reviewing the trial transcript to presenting your case at the appellate court.
