Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
Bad faith insurance law concerns situations where an insurance company fails to treat an insured person or claimant fairly and lawfully in handling an insurance claim. In McAllen, Texas, bad faith issues are governed primarily by Texas state law and interpreted by Texas courts. Typical bad faith conduct can include unreasonable delays, wrongful denial of a valid claim, lowball settlement offers, failure to investigate, misrepresentation of policy terms, and refusal to defend or settle third-party claims when doing so would expose the insured to an excess judgment. Remedies can include payment of benefits, extra-contractual damages, attorney fees, and in some cases punitive damages where the insurer acted with malice or gross disregard for the insureds rights.
Insurance claims often involve complex policy language, strict procedural rules, and time-sensitive deadlines. You may need a lawyer if:
- Your insurer denies a claim that you believe is covered under your policy.
- The insurer offers a settlement that is clearly below the reasonable value of your loss.
- The insurer unreasonably delays investigating or paying your claim and you are suffering financial harm because of the delay.
- The insurer misrepresents policy terms, coverage limits, or relevant facts.
- You face a third-party lawsuit and your insurer refuses to defend or to accept a reasonable settlement within policy limits, putting you at risk of a judgment above your coverage.
- You want to preserve your rights and collect evidence, calculate damages accurately, or pursue extra-contractual claims such as bad faith or statutory penalties.
An experienced local attorney can assess whether the insurer violated Texas law, explain potential remedies, preserve important evidence, handle communications with the insurer, and represent you in settlement negotiations or litigation.
Insurance regulation and bad faith law in McAllen follow Texas law. Key aspects to understand include:
- State Regulation: The Texas Department of Insurance regulates insurers operating in Texas and enforces the Texas Insurance Code. Consumer protections and complaint processes are administered at the state level.
- Unfair Practices: The Texas Insurance Code prohibits unfair or deceptive acts and practices by insurers. This includes certain statutory causes of action that consumers can pursue when insurers engage in deceptive, misleading, or unjust claims handling.
- Prompt Payment Rules: Texas has prompt payment provisions that require timely investigation and payment of valid claims. Violations may result in interest, statutory penalties, and attorney fees under applicable provisions.
- Common-Law Bad Faith and Extra-Contractual Claims: In addition to statutory remedies, Texas law recognizes extra-contractual claims in appropriate circumstances for insurer conduct that is unreasonable or malicious. These claims can seek damages beyond policy limits, including mental anguish and punitive damages, depending on the facts.
- Third-Party Duty to Settle: Texas law imposes duties on insurers when defending third-party suits. An insurer that refuses a reasonable settlement demand within policy limits can expose the insured to excess liability and may face bad faith exposure.
- Statutes of Limitation: Time limits apply to different claims. Breach of contract and statutory claims have varying limitation periods, so quick action is necessary to protect legal rights. Consult an attorney promptly to avoid losing the right to sue.
Bad faith occurs when an insurer handles a claim in an unreasonable, unfair, or deceptive manner that violates the insurer's duties to the insured. Examples include unjustified denial, excessive delay, inadequate investigation, misrepresentation of policy terms, or bad faith refusal to settle, especially when the insured faces excess judgments.
Not every unfavorable decision by an insurer is bad faith. Courts look for conduct that is objectively unreasonable, deceptive, arbitrary, or motivated by malice or conscious indifference. Key factors include the insurer's investigation, reliance on facts or experts, communication, and whether the insurer ignored clear coverage or settlement opportunities.
Potential damages may include the full value of the policy benefit, consequential damages caused by the delay or denial, extra-contractual damages such as mental anguish in some cases, attorney fees, statutory penalties where provided, and punitive damages if the conduct was malicious or showed gross negligence.
Yes. The Texas Department of Insurance accepts consumer complaints and investigates regulatory violations. Filing a complaint with TDI can prompt administrative review, but it does not replace the ability to pursue a private lawsuit. Complaints are useful evidence and may assist in resolving a dispute.
Deadline periods vary based on the type of claim. Breach of contract claims commonly fall under Texas limitation periods for contracts, while some statutory claims have different timeframes. Because timing rules are technical and important, consult an attorney quickly to determine applicable deadlines and preserve your right to sue.
Consider whether the offer fully compensates you for your loss, including damages beyond the policy amount and any extra-contractual harm. Discuss the offer with an experienced insurance attorney before accepting. Accepting a settlement may waive certain claims, so review the release language carefully.
Keep all communications with the insurer, claim forms, policy documents, photos, repair estimates, medical records, and any expert reports. Create a written log of phone calls with dates, times, and names. Preserve documents and electronic records and avoid destroying or altering relevant evidence.
Pursuing a bad faith claim against an insurer typically does not directly cause your premiums to rise, because the claim challenges the insurer's conduct. However, insurance companies consider many factors when setting premiums. Discuss concerns about future coverage with your attorney and insurance agents.
Many bad faith attorneys handle cases on a contingency-fee basis, meaning the attorney is paid a percentage of the recovery only if you win or settle. Some attorneys charge hourly rates or hybrid fees. Ask potential attorneys about fee structures, estimated costs, and how expenses will be handled during litigation.
Resolution time varies widely depending on case complexity, the amount in dispute, court schedules, discovery needs, and whether the case settles. Some matters settle in months while others can take a year or more if litigation heads to trial. Early legal assessment helps set realistic expectations.
For people in McAllen seeking further information or assistance, consider these resources:
- Texas Department of Insurance - the state regulator that handles consumer complaints, provides guidance, and monitors insurer compliance.
- Hidalgo County Clerk and local courts - for information on filing procedures and local court contacts.
- Texas State Bar - for lawyer referral services and information on attorney credentials.
- Local legal aid organizations that may provide low-cost or free legal assistance for qualifying individuals.
- Consumer protection agencies and business oversight offices that handle complaints against companies.
- Local bar associations in the Rio Grande Valley region that can provide referrals to experienced insurance litigators.
If you believe you are the victim of insurance bad faith in McAllen, consider the following practical steps:
- Document everything. Collect and organize your policy, claim forms, correspondence, photographs, estimates, medical bills, and any notes of conversations with the insurer.
- File an internal appeal. Use the insurer's internal appeal or complaint process and preserve records of that process.
- File a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance to initiate administrative review and create an official record of the dispute.
- Consult an attorney experienced in Texas bad faith and insurance law for a prompt case evaluation. An attorney can advise on deadlines, evidence preservation, potential damages, and the best strategies for settlement or litigation.
- Avoid signing releases or accepting settlement offers before speaking with counsel, as doing so may waive important rights.
- Consider alternative dispute resolution such as mediation if appropriate, while preserving the option to litigate if negotiations fail.
Acting quickly is important because legal rights can be lost if deadlines are missed and evidence is not preserved. A local McAllen attorney can guide you through the process, explain possible outcomes, and advocate for a fair resolution.
