Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
Birth injury law covers situations where a baby or mother suffers physical or psychological harm related to pregnancy, labour, delivery or immediate postnatal care. In Carlow, as elsewhere in Ireland, many birth injury matters fall within the broader area of medical negligence or personal injury law. A successful claim generally requires showing that a healthcare professional or institution owed a duty of care, that they breached the standard of care expected in the circumstances, and that the breach caused the injury.
Birth injuries can range from minor injuries with short-term effects to severe, life-changing conditions that require long-term care and support. Common examples include nerve damage, cerebral palsy, fractures, oxygen deprivation at birth and injuries caused by improper use of instruments during delivery. Cases can involve midwives, obstetricians, anaesthetists, hospital staff or institutional failures such as delays in arranging emergency transfer.
You may need a lawyer if you think a birth injury was preventable, if the consequences are significant, or if you need help navigating claims processes. Specific reasons to consult a solicitor include:
- Understanding whether the facts of your case amount to medical negligence rather than an unfortunate outcome.
- Preserving and obtaining vital evidence such as hospital notes, fetal monitoring records, delivery records and imaging reports.
- Handling pre-action procedures such as referral to the Injuries Board when required, and complying with time limits.
- Obtaining expert medical evidence to establish breach of duty and causation, and instructing appropriate specialists.
- Calculating and proving losses including past and future medical expenses, care costs, loss of earnings, and special needs supports.
- Dealing with complex defendants, including the State Claims Agency when the Health Service Executive is involved, or private hospital insurers.
- Negotiating settlements and preparing court documents if the case proceeds to litigation.
The legal framework relevant to birth injury claims in Carlow and the rest of Ireland includes a number of statutory and procedural elements:
- Duty of Care and Negligence: Healthcare providers owe patients a duty to provide care according to accepted standards. To prove negligence, a claimant must show breach of that duty and that the breach caused the injury.
- Injuries Board: Most personal injury claims in Ireland must first be referred to the Injuries Board for assessment unless exempt. This administrative step can lead to an assessed award or clearance to commence court proceedings if the assessment is rejected.
- State Claims Agency: Claims against public health bodies or state-employed clinicians are often handled through the State Claims Agency. Procedures for dealing with these defendants can differ from claims against private practitioners or hospitals.
- Limitation Periods: Time limits apply to bringing claims. There are special rules for children and persons who lack capacity, and limitation rules can be paused in some circumstances. It is essential to act promptly to avoid losing the right to sue.
- Court Jurisdiction and Procedure: More serious or high-value cases are generally brought in the High Court, while other claims may fall within the Circuit Court. Court procedures include disclosure, expert reports and, where necessary, trial.
- Remedies and Damages: Compensation can include general damages for pain and suffering, special damages for past and future financial losses, costs of care and equipment, and awards for ongoing support or educational needs.
A birth injury is any harm to the mother or baby related to pregnancy, labour, delivery or care shortly after birth. This includes physical injuries such as fractures or nerve damage, neurological harm including hypoxic brain injuries, and conditions linked to delayed or inappropriate treatment.
Not every poor outcome is negligence. You may have a claim if there is evidence that standard practices were not followed, decisions were unreasonably delayed, monitoring was inadequate, or interventions were improperly performed, and that those failures caused the injury. A lawyer will usually obtain and review the medical records and arrange independent expert opinions to test liability and causation.
Strict time limits apply. There are special rules for children and people who lack capacity. Limitation rules vary depending on the circumstances, so it is important to seek advice early. A solicitor can confirm the deadline that applies in your situation and advise on whether any extension or exception might apply.
Many personal injury claims in Ireland must be referred to the Injuries Board before proceedings can be issued. There are exceptions, for example in certain clinical negligence cases or fatal claims. Your solicitor will advise whether the Injuries Board process applies to your case and will manage the referral if required.
Potential defendants include individual clinicians such as doctors or midwives, private hospitals, and public bodies such as the Health Service Executive. Claims against the State or HSE are typically handled through the State Claims Agency.
Key evidence includes hospital and maternity records, fetal monitoring traces, scans and imaging, notes from labour and delivery, antenatal records, and any correspondence. Expert medical reports are crucial to explain whether care fell below accepted standards and whether that caused the injury.
Timelines vary widely. Some matters settle after pre-action negotiation or an Injuries Board assessment within months, while complex cases with significant injury and expert evidence can take several years if court proceedings are required. The severity of injury and complexity of causation and quantum affect the duration.
Many cases settle before trial after negotiation or mediation. Trials occur when parties cannot agree on liability or compensation. Your solicitor will aim to resolve the matter without a trial where possible, while preparing the case as though it will proceed to court if needed.
Compensation can cover general damages for pain and suffering, special damages for past and future financial losses, costs of medical treatment and rehabilitation, home adaptations, special equipment, care costs, and loss of earnings or earning capacity. For children with lifelong needs, awards for future care and education support can be significant.
Fee arrangements vary. Many solicitors in personal injury and clinical negligence cases work on a conditional fee basis where fees are recoverable from the opponent if the claim succeeds, subject to court approval and scale. You should ask about fees, disbursements such as expert fees, and who will pay these costs if the claim is unsuccessful. A clear written retainer will set out the terms.
Below are public bodies and organisations that can be useful sources of information or assistance when you are considering a birth injury matter in Carlow:
- Injuries Board - for assessment procedures that apply to many personal injury cases.
- State Claims Agency - handles clinical negligence claims involving the State or public health services.
- Health Service Executive - the national public health provider and point of contact for complaints about public hospital care.
- Medical Council - the regulator of doctors in Ireland; it handles fitness to practise and professional standards complaints.
- Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) - provides oversight and standards for health services.
- Law Society of Ireland - professional body for solicitors; they can help you find solicitors in your area and explain professional conduct standards.
- The Bar of Ireland - professional body for barristers who may advise or represent in court.
- Citizens Information - provides general information about legal rights and public services and can explain access to legal aid or other supports.
- Legal Aid Board - provides information on eligibility for civil legal aid, which may be available in certain cases for those on limited means.
- Local support and disability organisations - local charities and national groups that support families of children with disabilities can assist with practical planning and care resources.
If you believe you or your child has suffered a birth injury and you are considering legal action, follow these practical steps:
- Seek early legal advice - contact a solicitor experienced in clinical negligence and birth injury matters to review the facts and advise on prospects of success and next steps.
- Collect records - ask for copies of all maternity, antenatal, delivery and postnatal records. Your solicitor can help request these formally.
- Protect evidence - avoid discarding any documentation, photographs or correspondence that relate to the birth and subsequent care.
- Get medical input - a solicitor will usually arrange for independent medical experts to review your records and provide an opinion on whether care fell below accepted standards.
- Consider complaints and redress routes - your solicitor can advise whether to make a complaint to the HSE or hospital, to engage the State Claims Agency, or to refer the matter to the Injuries Board where applicable.
- Ask about costs and funding - discuss fee arrangements, likely disbursements and whether legal aid or alternative funding options might apply.
- Plan for the future - if a child has ongoing needs, start gathering assessments of care, therapy requirements, education needs and cost estimates to assist with any claim for future support.
Remember, the law around birth injuries can be complex and time-sensitive. A legally qualified adviser with experience in clinical negligence can explain how the rules apply to your situation, protect your rights and guide you through each stage of the process.
