Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
Birth injury law in Dunedin sits at the intersection of health law, personal injury compensation and patient rights. Many birth injuries arise from events during pregnancy, labour or immediately after birth and can range from peripheral nerve injuries and fractures to more serious brain injuries. In New Zealand most physical injuries arising from treatment or accident are managed through the national accident compensation scheme run by the Accident Compensation Corporation - ACC. That system affects the options available for compensation and the way families pursue answers and remedies.
Local care in Dunedin is delivered through Te Whatu Ora - Southern and Dunedin Hospital, as well as independent midwives and private practitioners. Families seeking legal assistance often need a mix of medical advice, administrative action with ACC, formal complaints to health regulators, and sometimes civil legal advice where ACC entitlements or other legal routes are involved.
Families consider a lawyer when a child or mother has suffered a significant injury and they need help with one or more of the following:
- Understanding ACC entitlements and whether the injury qualifies as an ACC treatment injury or birth-related injury.
- Seeking compensation or support that may not be covered by ACC, including claims that fall outside ACC coverage.
- Making a formal complaint to the Health and Disability Commissioner or assisting with medical records and expert reports.
- Dealing with complex disputes with hospitals, independent midwives, or Te Whatu Ora - Southern about the standard of care.
- Exploring civil options where they may exist - for example where exemplary damages, privacy breaches or other non-ACC claims are relevant.
- Obtaining technical medical evidence - arranging independent medical experts, second opinions and interpreting records.
- Securing interim practical support, such as organised care plans, funding for equipment or home modifications while longer term entitlements are determined.
Several legal frameworks are especially relevant in Dunedin and across New Zealand when dealing with birth injuries:
- Accident Compensation Act 2001 - ACC provides no-fault cover for personal injury, including many treatment injuries and injuries suffered at birth. ACC entitlements commonly include funding for treatment, rehabilitation, aids and appliances, and in some cases weekly compensation and lump sums for permanent impairment.
- Health and Disability Commissioner Act 1994 and the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights - These protect patient rights, including the right to be treated with care and respect, the right to informed consent, and the right to complain about care. The Health and Disability Commissioner handles complaints and can make recommendations, and may refer matters to professional disciplinary bodies.
- Privacy Act 2020 - Governs access to and handling of medical records. Individuals have rights to obtain copies of their health information and to request corrections.
- Limitation Act 2010 - Sets time limits for bringing civil claims. Time limits can be strict and may be different for children. It is important to ask a lawyer about applicable deadlines as soon as possible.
- Medical regulatory and disciplinary frameworks - The Medical Council of New Zealand, the Nursing Council, and other regulators can investigate professional fitness-to-practise and discipline where care breaches standards.
A birth injury is an injury sustained by a mother or baby during pregnancy, labour, birth or shortly after birth. Legally, these injuries are assessed in terms of cause, whether ACC covers the injury as a treatment injury or personal injury, and whether there is any basis for complaint or further civil action. The specific circumstances and available remedies influence how the case proceeds.
Yes - for most physical injuries ACC is the primary route for compensation and supports. Lodging an ACC claim early is important to secure treatment funding and rehabilitation services. A lawyer can help determine whether the injury is covered and assist with the ACC process.
New Zealand’s ACC system generally prevents suing for personal injury in the usual civil way. There are limited exceptions - for example, claims for exemplary damages, breaches of privacy, or actions where ACC does not cover the injury. Because the rules are complex, legal advice is necessary to understand whether a civil claim is possible in your case.
ACC entitlements can include medical and rehabilitation costs, aids and equipment, home help, travel costs, weekly compensation where appropriate, and lump-sum payments for permanent impairment in some cases. Civil claims, where they are possible, can seek damages not available through ACC, but such claims are uncommon and fact-specific. A lawyer can explain possible outcomes based on your circumstances.
Timelines vary widely. ACC decisions may take weeks to months depending on complexity and the need for specialist assessments. Complaints to the Health and Disability Commissioner can take several months. If litigation or complex investigations are involved, the process can take years. Early legal and medical advice can reduce delays and ensure key evidence is preserved.
Under the Privacy Act you have a right to request your medical records from hospitals, Te Whatu Ora - Southern, private practitioners or midwives. Request in writing, be specific about dates and types of documents, and allow reasonable time for a response. If you have difficulty obtaining records, a lawyer can send a formal request and advise on next steps.
Complaining to the Health and Disability Commissioner is a common and often helpful step. The Commissioner investigates breaches of the Code of Rights and can recommend remedies, including apologies, systemic changes and referrals to professional regulators. A lawyer can advise whether a complaint is appropriate and help prepare evidence.
Key evidence includes clinical notes from pregnancy and labour, delivery records, neonatal records, photographic or video evidence if available, expert medical opinions, and records of ongoing care and expenses. Keep a clear timeline and copies of all correspondence. Lawyers often work with independent medical experts to interpret records and explain causation.
Yes. Parents or guardians can act on behalf of a child when making ACC claims and complaints, and legal proceedings where appropriate. Limitation rules are often more flexible for minors, but it remains important to act promptly so that entitlements are not lost and records remain available.
Costs vary between firms. Many specialist birth-injury or clinical negligence lawyers offer an initial consultation at low or no cost and may work on a conditional fee basis or a funding arrangement. Legal aid for civil clinical negligence is limited but possible in exceptional circumstances. Community legal services, the Citizens Advice Bureau and Dunedin Community Law Centre can provide free guidance and referrals.
Ministry of Health - national health policies and information relevant to maternal and neonatal care.
Te Whatu Ora - Southern - local health services and information for Dunedin and the southern region.
Dunedin Hospital - the main public hospital providing maternity and neonatal services in Dunedin.
Accident Compensation Corporation - for claims relating to treatment injuries and birth-related injuries.
Health and Disability Commissioner - for complaints under the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights.
Medical Council of New Zealand and other professional regulatory bodies - for reports about professional conduct or fitness to practise.
Privacy Commissioner - advice on accessing and correcting personal health information.
Community Legal Centres and Dunedin Community Law Centre - local free legal advice and referral services.
Cerebral Palsy Society of New Zealand, Brain Injury Association of New Zealand, Parent to Parent New Zealand - national support groups for families affected by childhood disability and brain injury.
Step 1 - Secure immediate medical needs: Prioritise urgent medical care and any rehabilitation or supports your child or mother requires. Contact ACC to lodge a claim if a physical injury has occurred.
Step 2 - Collect and preserve documents: Request and keep copies of all medical records, birth summaries, discharge notes and any correspondence with health services. Make a clear timeline of events.
Step 3 - Get independent medical advice: Where possible obtain a second medical opinion so you understand the nature and likely causes of the injury. A specialist report can be essential for complaints or legal advice.
Step 4 - Consider a complaint to the Health and Disability Commissioner: If you believe patient rights were breached, a complaint can lead to investigation and recommendations. A lawyer can help prepare this complaint.
Step 5 - Seek legal advice early: Contact a lawyer experienced in birth injury, clinical negligence and ACC matters. Ask about fee arrangements, time limits and the likely routes for obtaining support or compensation.
Step 6 - Access local support networks: Reach out to local and national support organisations to help with practical issues - care needs, equipment and emotional support. They can also point you to advocacy and community legal services.
When to act - Limitation periods and procedural requirements can affect your options. Even if you are unsure about the strength of a claim, speak to a lawyer promptly so you do not miss critical deadlines and so you can secure evidence and expert opinions while they are most reliable.
Final note - Birth injury cases are often emotionally and practically challenging. Legal advice will help you understand entitlements under ACC, the role of complaints processes, and whether any civil remedies may be available in your circumstances. A trusted lawyer can guide you through medical records, expert evidence and interactions with health agencies while you focus on your family.
