Existing user? Sign in
Share your needs with us, get contacted by law firms.
Free. Takes 2 min.
Brooklyn, United States Attorneys in related practice areas.
Lawsuits and disputes in Brooklyn are handled under New York State civil procedure and local court rules that apply in Kings County. Brooklyn residents and businesses bring civil claims ranging from small claims and landlord-tenant matters to breach of contract, personal injury, employment disputes, consumer complaints, and complex commercial litigation. The local court system includes Civil Court parts that handle lower-value claims and Housing Court for landlord-tenant cases, and the Kings County Supreme Court for more significant civil suits. Many disputes are resolved before trial through negotiation, mediation, arbitration, or settlement conferences, but some matters proceed to full trial and post-judgment enforcement.
This guide explains common situations that bring people to court, highlights local rules and practical steps, answers common questions, and points to resources to help you decide how to proceed if you face a dispute in Brooklyn.
Not every dispute requires a lawyer, but many situations benefit from legal advice or representation. A lawyer can help you understand your rights, preserve important deadlines, evaluate damages and exposure, draft and review legal documents, and represent you in negotiations, court hearings, and trials. Common situations where you may need a lawyer include:
- Serious personal injury or wrongful death cases where medical costs and lost wages are involved.
- Contract disputes involving significant sums or complicated contract terms.
- Landlord-tenant matters that could lead to eviction, large rent arrears, major repairs, or complex lease interpretations.
- Employment claims involving discrimination, wage and hour violations, wrongful termination, or restrictive covenants.
- Consumer fraud, deceptive business practices, or warranty disputes with businesses.
- Business disputes among partners, shareholders, or suppliers that threaten the continued operation of a company.
- Cases where an opposing party is represented by counsel, which can create procedural and tactical disadvantages for someone acting alone.
Key local and state rules you should know when facing a lawsuit or dispute in Brooklyn include:
- Court structure - Kings County includes Civil Court, Housing Court, Family Court, and the Kings County Supreme Court. Civil Court handles many lower-value civil claims and small claims. Housing Court hears landlord-tenant matters and code enforcement issues. Supreme Court handles more complex and higher-value civil litigation.
- Small claims and civil claim limits - New York provides simplified small claims procedures for lower-dollar disputes. Civil Court covers many other claims up to a statutorily defined limit. Larger or more complex disputes typically belong in Supreme Court.
- Statutes of limitations - New York sets time limits for bringing different kinds of claims. For example, many personal injury and property damage claims generally must be filed within three years from the date of injury, while most breach of contract claims are subject to a six-year limitation. Deadlines vary by claim type and specific facts - missing a deadline can bar your case, so act promptly.
- Pleading and service rules - Lawsuits require properly drafted pleadings and correct service of legal papers on the opposing party. New York civil procedure has strict rules about how claims are started and how parties are notified.
- Discovery and disclosure - Once a suit is underway, parties exchange information through discovery. Discovery tools include document demands, interrogatories, depositions, and requests for admission. New York courts expect parties to cooperate, but disputes over discovery often require judicial intervention.
- Alternative dispute resolution - Courts frequently encourage or require mediation, settlement conferences, or arbitration to resolve disputes without trial. Arbitration may be mandatory if the parties agreed to it in a contract.
- Fee structures - Attorneys in civil cases may work on an hourly basis, flat fees, or contingency agreements. Contingency fees are common in personal injury matters, meaning the lawyer is paid a percentage of recovery if the case succeeds.
To start a civil lawsuit you must file a complaint or summons and complaint in the appropriate court, pay any filing fees or request a fee waiver if eligible, and properly serve the opposing party with the court papers according to New York rules. The correct court depends on the type and amount of your claim. Small claims and many lower-value matters are filed in Civil Court, while higher-value or more complex cases typically go to Supreme Court. Because procedural missteps can derail a case, consider consulting a lawyer or the court clerk for guidance before filing.
Time limits to file a claim - called statutes of limitations - depend on the type of case. Common examples are three years for many personal injury actions and six years for most breach of contract claims. Other claims have different deadlines, and certain events can toll or extend timelines. Determine the exact deadline for your claim quickly and consult a lawyer if you are near the deadline.
Yes, you have the right to represent yourself, which is called proceeding pro se. Small claims court is designed for non-lawyers and has simplified procedures. However, representing yourself in more complex matters involves strict procedural rules, discovery obligations, and legal strategy decisions. If the stakes are high or the opposing party is represented, retaining a lawyer is often advisable.
Costs vary by case type and attorney. Common fee arrangements include hourly billing, flat fees for defined services, and contingency fees where the lawyer takes a percentage of the recovery in successful personal injury or certain commercial claims. You may also need to cover expenses such as court filing fees, process server fees, expert witness fees, and copying costs. Ask about fee structure, likely expenses, and whether the lawyer offers free initial consultations or payment plans.
If the defendant is properly served and fails to respond within the time permitted by law, you may seek a default judgment. A default judgment can allow you to obtain the relief requested if you prove your claims and damages as required by the court. Even after a default, there may be procedural steps to complete before the judgment is entered and enforced, so consult an attorney or the court clerk for the correct process.
Case timelines vary widely. A small claims matter may resolve in weeks to months. A contested civil case in Supreme Court can take many months to several years, depending on complexity, discovery disputes, court schedules, and whether the case settles. Mediation or settlement negotiations can shorten timelines. Plan for uncertainty and discuss timing with counsel early on.
Discovery is the process by which parties exchange information and evidence relevant to the lawsuit. It typically includes document requests, written questions called interrogatories, depositions where witnesses are questioned under oath, and requests for admission. Good discovery prepares your case, reveals the opponent's evidence, and often exposes opportunities for settlement. Failing to comply with discovery orders can result in sanctions.
Mediation is a voluntary or court-ordered negotiation process led by a neutral mediator who helps the parties pursue a settlement. Arbitration is a private, less formal adjudication before an arbitrator whose decision may be binding or non-binding depending on prior agreement. Both methods can be faster and less expensive than a trial. Whether to agree depends on the dispute, prior contractual obligations, confidentiality concerns, and whether you need a judicial record or appeal rights. Discuss the pros and cons with an attorney before consenting to alternate dispute resolution.
Damages depend on the type of claim. Compensatory damages reimburse actual losses such as medical bills, property damage, lost wages, and repair costs. Pain and suffering or emotional distress may be recoverable in personal injury cases. In some cases, punitive damages can be awarded to punish particularly wrongful conduct, and attorneys fees may be recoverable when a statute or contract allows. The exact method of calculation and recoverability of certain damages depends on law and the evidence you can present.
Winning a judgment is only one step - collecting on it is another. Enforcement tools include wage garnishment, bank account levies, property liens, and seizure of certain assets. Some collection methods require additional court proceedings or a judgment creditor application. Legal and practical obstacles can affect collectability, such as the debtor's financial condition and exemptions. Consult counsel or a judgment enforcement specialist to pursue collection options effectively.
Local courts and organizations that can help with procedural questions, self-help materials, or referrals include:
- Kings County Civil Court and Kings County Supreme Court - local court offices provide filing information, calendars, and clerk assistance for procedural questions.
- Brooklyn Housing Court - for landlord-tenant matters, emergency repairs, rent issues, and related housing disputes.
- New York State Unified Court System - state courts offer self-help guides and forms for common civil matters and small claims.
- Legal Aid Society - provides free or low-cost legal help to eligible individuals in civil matters, including housing and certain consumer or government benefits disputes.
- Brooklyn Bar Association and local lawyer referral services - help you find attorneys experienced in specific areas of litigation.
- Volunteer lawyers programs and pro bono clinics - community legal clinics often offer brief advice, document review, or referrals.
- New York State Attorney General - for consumer protection complaints and investigations into deceptive business practices.
- Small Claims Court guides and self-help centers - for guidance on preparing and presenting a small claims case.
- Mediation and arbitration organizations - private dispute resolution providers and court-sponsored mediation programs that handle civil and commercial matters.
If you are facing a lawsuit or dispute in Brooklyn, follow these steps to protect your rights and improve your chances of a good outcome:
- Act quickly - identify any filing deadlines or urgent relief that may be needed, such as temporary restraining orders or orders of protection.
- Preserve evidence - keep contracts, emails, texts, invoices, photos, medical records, receipts, and any other documentation relevant to your claim or defense. Do not delete communications or alter records.
- Organize your timeline - create a clear chronology of events, noting dates, people involved, and actions taken.
- Consider early legal advice - even an initial consultation can identify key risks, procedural steps, and likely costs. Ask about fee structures and whether a lawyer offers a free or low-cost initial meeting.
- Explore alternative dispute resolution - evaluate whether mediation or arbitration could resolve your dispute faster or with less expense.
- Use court resources - visit the appropriate court clerk or self-help center for form requirements, filing procedures, and fee waiver information if you cannot afford fees.
- If you hire a lawyer - get the engagement terms in writing, understand the scope of representation, fee arrangement, and communication expectations, and provide your lawyer with all relevant documents promptly.
- Stay informed and realistic - litigation can be slow, emotionally taxing, and costly. Consider the practical costs and benefits of litigation versus settlement, and make decisions based on legal advice and your long-term goals.
Facing a dispute can be stressful, but timely action, good documentation, and informed choices about representation and strategy will help you navigate the process in Brooklyn. If you are unsure where to start, contact a local legal aid office, bar association referral service, or an experienced attorney for a case evaluation.
